My Roamio Pro drive is dead and I can exchange it for a Edge for $250. It will transfer my lifetime over with it. I'm trying to decide if I stay with Tivo at this point. I've used Tivo since the Series 1, but I'm not excited about the new interface. Tried it previously and hated it. With my condo association's Comcast agreement I receive a free DVR box. We have two TVs so I would need to spend $10 a month for a 2nd box based on our agreement. The X1 box would be cloud based content and I think I would miss having locally stored content that I can quickly move through. I miss on-demand programming and I would get that back with Xfinity. Not sure what to do and if I should stay with Tivo or not. My cable is already included in my association dues. Any reasons to stay with Tivo at this point?