From the perspective of the S3 there are no other differences so in a way it does make it a "CinemaStar".drew00001 said:You can reduce the acoustics on a deskstar, but doing so does not make it a Cinemastar.
Who else lists them (HCS721010KLA330) for sale?mchiles said:Interesting... Their price is DOUBLE what others list them for.
I want a CinemaStar because I want a drive that is made for 24/7/365 use for a long period of time (years). I don't understand how much difference there is between a "regular drive" and a "24/7" drive. The FAQ on this forum on external drives recommends a "24/7 drive". I am just worried because there is no way to back this up. If that drive fails you lose all recordings contained on it.jlib said:From the perspective of the S3 there are no other differences so in a way it does make it a "CinemaStar".
There is no such thing as a "24/7 drive". It is just a made-up concept. A warm fuzzy if you will. At least none of the manufacturers use it or any similar notion. The only difference between the CinemaStar and the DeskStar is the firmware.MikeMacMan said:I want a CinemaStar because I want a drive that is made for 24/7/365 use for a long period of time (years). I don't understand how much difference there is between a "regular drive" and a "24/7" drive. The FAQ on this forum on external drives recommends a "24/7 drive". I am just worried because there is no way to back this up. If that drive fails you lose all recordings contained on it.
From the Series 3 eSATA FAQ:jlib said:There is no such thing as a "24/7 drive". It is just a make-up concept. A warm fuzzy if you will. At least none of the manufacturers use it or any similar notion. The only difference between the CinemaStar and the DeskStar is the firmware.
From FAQ 25: "Ultimately, one must decide whether they are willing to pay a premium for extra 'peace of mind.'"MikeMacMan said:From the Series 3 eSATA FAQ:
29. What are recommended drives to use with a separate eSATA enclosure?
Members concerned about long-term reliability should choose a drive certified for 24/7 operation.
Even a manufacturer's so-called Enterprise level drives aren't certified for 24/7 usage as opposed to their more mainstream offerings. An Enterprise drive will have more performance for sure (performance unneeded by the S3, by the way) but none of the manufacturers imply, let alone certify, that even their low-end drives are not capable of 24/7 usage.MikeMacMan said:From the Series 3 eSATA FAQ:
29. What are recommended drives to use with a separate eSATA enclosure?
Members concerned about long-term reliability should choose a drive certified for 24/7 operation.
The Ultrastar is $399 on Newegg and the Cinemastar is $758.09 on memory4less.com. Which one is overkill?jlib said:The UltraStar is overkill. What is the difference between the other 2 DeskStars? They are both listed as bare drives so the difference is not the retail package.
Edit: Newegg has the DeskStar with the 0A34915 SKU mislabled. It is the retail box package not the OEM bare drive. They are both the same drive. The cheaper one has no box and no cables are furnished.
Ultrastar and other 'near line storage/enterprise' drives have accelerometers and software for compensating for RV (rotational vibration). The base drives are sensitive to vibration from other drives or even system fans. SAS drives in the same enclosure as SATA drives can vibrate the crud out of a 'desktop' SATA drive. S3 is a very controlled environment and shouldnt need the additional RV tolerance.drew00001 said:Newegg.com now has 3 versions of Hitachi's 1gb drive: 2 deskstar's and an ultrastar. The prices range from $359 to $399. Does anyone know if the Ultrastar will be better for a S3 upgrade or eSata. I don't otherwise plan on paying the extreme premium for the Cinemastar.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...&N=2000150014+103530090&name=800GB+and+higher