TiVo Community Forum banner
1 - 20 of 75 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm running Windows 10.

Tivo Deskto was working fine under Windows 10 until about a week ago then found it was no longer linking to account and all attempts to link give error message ""unable to link to your account" even though I can use the same email/password to log on to the Tivo site. I can also successfully transfer video to the Tivo using Pytivo which uses the same data MAK/email/password that Tivo Desktop uses.

I've tried a dozen or more times over several days to make it link. I've uninstalled and reinstalled a few times including run of tivodesktop cleaner, reboot Windows, rebooted Tivo etc. I've read every post I could find here and elsewhere on the issue with no answers that worked.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.
 

·
in the other Alabama
Joined
·
20,955 Posts
I'm running Windows 10.

Tivo Deskto was working fine under Windows 10 until about a week ago then found it was no longer linking to account and all attempts to link give error message ""unable to link to your account" even though I can use the same email/password to log on to the Tivo site. I can also successfully transfer video to the Tivo using Pytivo which uses the same data MAK/email/password that Tivo Desktop uses.

I've tried a dozen or more times over several days to make it link. I've uninstalled and reinstalled a few times including run of tivodesktop cleaner, reboot Windows, rebooted Tivo etc. I've read every post I could find here and elsewhere on the issue with no answers that worked.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.
It has been posted on the help thread that if you enter your email address as [email protected] it will link. It doesn't work for me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
"It has been posted on the help thread that if you enter your email address as [email protected] it will link. It doesn't work for me."

Wow! I didn't think it would work but decided to give it a try. Actually the form you quoted above [email protected] did not work BUT putting the whole thing in caps like this: [email protected] did work for me.

Thanks Again, the programmer that, no doubt unwittingly, placed that limit in the code must have been smoking something strong.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Did you try with both domain and name in all caps?

Also, someone suggested that log on problems can occur with special characters are in the password. You might try a different password setup.
 

·
HD Tech
Joined
·
1,030 Posts
Well, that is pretty arrogant of TiVo. :mad:

We're just gonna disable that piece of software we sold you without any notice, like a "sorry" email, and tough.

So I guess no more push to the TiVo from the computer using Desktop Plus, huh? Guess I'll go see if pull still works, or it's all dead.

No combination of upper/lower case worked for me. They must have disabled that now.

Really annoying.
 

·
in the other Alabama
Joined
·
20,955 Posts
There are alternatives that are more powerful, well supported, and much more complicated.

I can't get in either. Case changes don't help. But the only reason I started using it was to save special programs. Now I have a retired Premiere for that.
 

·
HD Tech
Joined
·
1,030 Posts
There are alternatives that are more powerful, well supported, and much more complicated.
Yeah, I know. It's the "much more complicated" part that annoys me the most.

I've got pyTivo installed, and have played with it a few times but found it annoyingly geeky. And that comment comes from an annoying geek who gets into the minutiae.

And "well supported" is not very comforting when TiVo can disable the "reach-around push" function any time they feel like it. Like they just did with Desktop Plus.

TiVo user for well over a decade (Series 1, 2, 3, DirecTiVo, Roamio+Minis) but based on events the last few months, I'm no longer planning on putting a bigger drive in my lifetime Roamio, nor am I adding any more Minis (much as I'd like to). The service has gone from reliably stable to volatile and unpredictable. Who knows what the upcoming merger will bring next?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,461 Posts
Yeah, I know. It's the "much more complicated" part that annoys me the most.

I've got pyTivo installed, and have played with it a few times but found it annoyingly geeky. And that comment comes from an annoying geek who gets into the minutiae.
If you think pyTivo is "annoyingly geeky", them I think you vastly overrate your own geekiness.

And "well supported" is not very comforting when TiVo can disable the "reach-around push" function any time they feel like it. Like they just did with Desktop Plus.
The didn't "disable" push, even for TD+. Maybe they plan to, but as of right now, there is merely something odd going on with the servers.

In any case, I know why pull is not a viable alternative for me for one of my TiVos (it's remote). Why is it not an alternative for you?

TiVo user for well over a decade (Series 1, 2, 3, DirecTiVo, Roamio+Minis) but based on events the last few months, I'm no longer planning on putting a bigger drive in my lifetime Roamio, nor am I adding any more Minis (much as I'd like to). The service has gone from reliably stable to volatile and unpredictable. Who knows what the upcoming merger will bring next?
My biggest issue is that I have a large collection of recordings on an NAS with Gracenote metadata that will now have screwy data when transferred back to the TiVo.

I'm hoping that when all of the dust settles, there will be a way to make one of the metadata creation programs work again, but I have my doubts.
 

·
HD Tech
Joined
·
1,030 Posts
The didn't "disable" push, even for TD+. Maybe they plan to, but as of right now, there is merely something odd going on with the servers.
That is false. From an online response here on tivocommunity from TiVo's Ira Bahr 11 days ago: "The PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform."

No longer supported. I'd call that "disabled", the end of it. You may interpret that as you wish.

Without being able to connect to TiVo's servers to tie Desktop Plus to my TiVo account, the Desktop Plus server won't start. Without the Desktop Plus Server running, the TiVo can't see the video, audio, or image files on the computer to pull them, and Desktop Plus can't push them to the TiVo. Not exactly that "Unified Entertainment System" the TiVo website brags about. Since I have never had an interest in getting files from the TiVo onto my computer, this for me is the end of Desktop Plus functionality.

There is nothing to say they won't stop pytivo working in a week or two, since "the PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform.". That seems more likely than not, based on Bahr's statement. So what some of us are left with is Plex on TiVo, which from all I've read here is not very good. Plex is fine, it's TiVo's version that is poorly implemented.

Time to see what Roku or Amazon Fire looks like when playing my computer's content.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,461 Posts
That is false. From an online response here on tivocommunity from TiVo's Ira Bahr 11 days ago: "The PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform."

No longer supported. I'd call that "disabled", the end of it. You may interpret that as you wish.

Without being able to connect to TiVo's servers to tie Desktop Plus to my TiVo account, the Desktop Plus server won't start. Without the Desktop Plus Server running, the TiVo can't see the video, audio, or image files on the computer to pull them, and Desktop Plus can't push them to the TiVo. Not exactly that "Unified Entertainment System" the TiVo website brags about. Since I have never had an interest in getting files from the TiVo onto my computer, this for me is the end of Desktop Plus functionality.

There is nothing to say they won't stop pytivo working in a week or two, since "the PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform.". That seems more likely than not, based on Bahr's statement. So what some of us are left with is Plex on TiVo, which from all I've read here is not very good. Plex is fine, it's TiVo's version that is poorly implemented.

Time to see what Roku or Amazon Fire looks like when playing my computer's content.
And I thought I was a pessimist. Maybe you're right but "not supported" != "disabled". They'd have to disable it in the TiVo s/w. I've actually had the fear that they might do that very thing.

It's been years since they were actively supporting TD and transfers still work. If the current problem with pushes was actually them shutting it off, why not just do it? Maybe they're trying to find out who will complain, so why don't you complain to TiVo rather than just uselessly venting your ire here and saying I'm wrong about something when in fact you have no idea what is really going on.

There are things that never were supported but still work fine. 30 second skip for one.

I've never used TD+ but regular TD works just fine w/o contacting the servers and I'd be very surprised if there wasn't a way to get TD+ to do the same.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
304 Posts
This has got to be one of craziest types of failures I've seen. Unless it magically started working based on a change on the server side that just happen to be made at the right time between my failed attempts, then the working permuation is

[email protected]

I tried all lower case, I tried all upper case, I tried just the first part upper with the last part lower. But the above is what worked, and I don't want to undo it to experiment to prove to myself what works and what doesn't work.
 

·
HD Tech
Joined
·
1,030 Posts
This has got to be one of craziest types of failures I've seen. Unless it magically started working based on a change on the server side that just happen to be made at the right time between my failed attempts, then the working permuation is

[email protected]

I tried all lower case, I tried all upper case, I tried just the first part upper with the last part lower. But the above is what worked, and I don't want to undo it to experiment to prove to myself what works and what doesn't work.
That's what TiVo support is suggesting (for now) on their site, but it does not work for me. I added my post to the people complaining about it.

I did get the Desktop server running again after doing a complete wipe and reinstall of Desktop, but still can't link to their server, so can't 'publish' content to my Roamio. At least I can now see the computer from it and pull footage.

TiVo support says they're looking for a fix, but I'd be surprised, based on Ira Bahr's statement that this sort of function will no longer be supported, if they find one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,934 Posts
TiVo support says they're looking for a fix, but I'd be surprised, based on Ira Bahr's statement that this sort of function will no longer be supported, if they find one.
Ira said that the program is no longer supported for some (unspecified) reason, and left vague the question of whether the function would eventually be replaced. TiVos still "support" accessing content through a builtin webserver; at least "support" in the sense that it still works.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,461 Posts
Ira said that the program is no longer supported for some (unspecified) reason, and left vague the question of whether the function would eventually be replaced. TiVos still "support" accessing content through a builtin webserver; at least "support" in the sense that it still works.
Really? Just the program?

As far as the impact on those using TiVo Desktop software, some programs recorded before the guide data update (using Gracenote data) that are restored afterwards (using Rovi data) may see odd metadata changes. This will happen mostly for less popular shows. This isn't ideal, but the PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform. As for the mobile app, this continues to be a supported platform and will be transitioned fully as with all of our existing software platforms.
Lot's of unsupported things still work, even some that were never supported. There's just no guarantee that they will continue to work in the future.
 

·
HD Tech
Joined
·
1,030 Posts
Ira said that the program is no longer supported for some (unspecified) reason, and left vague the question of whether the function would eventually be replaced. TiVos still "support" accessing content through a builtin webserver; at least "support" in the sense that it still works.
http://www.tivocommunity.com/tivo-vb/showthread.php?p=10970111#post10970111

"PC transfer is no longer a supported feature on our platform"

Seems not vague, in fact very clear to me. I don't know how he could have been more direct.

Whether it continues working is up in the air, but my experience has been that features no longer supported rarely get fixed if they break.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,934 Posts
"the PC transfer..."

Which in context I took to refer to specific program which does the transfer. But I can see how it could be interpreted otherwise. Not knowing why they were compelled to remove support, I don't think a firm conclusion can be drawn. You are of course free to draw a different conclusion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,461 Posts
"the PC transfer..."

Which in context I took to refer to specific program which does the transfer. But I can see how it could be interpreted otherwise. Not knowing why they were compelled to remove support, I don't think a firm conclusion can be drawn. You are of course free to draw a different conclusion.
TD doesn't run on the TiVo, so it cannot be what he referred to as a "feature on our platform".
 
1 - 20 of 75 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top