TiVo Community Forum banner

TiVo HD - Information for SA CableCard Users

11480 Views 83 Replies 41 Participants Last post by  Dr_Diablo
Hey guys, another update regarding the progress being made.

We've identified a potential fix for the issues some of you have experienced with Scientific Atlanta CableCards, and it's testing very well in beta. It's a change that needs to soak in testing for a bit yet (to set expectations, we're looking at minimum a couple of weeks). So far, so good though.

Again, it appears that a software update will resolve the issue. I'll keep you posted when the new update is ready.

Thanks again,
Pony
1 - 20 of 84 Posts
TiVoPony said:
Hey guys, another update regarding the progress being made.

We've identified a potential fix for the issues some of you have experienced with Scientific Atlanta CableCards, and it's testing very well in beta. It's a change that needs to soak in testing for a bit yet (to set expectations, we're looking at minimum a couple of weeks). So far, so good though.

Again, it appears that a software update will resolve the issue. I'll keep you posted when the new update is ready.

Thanks again,
Pony
Thanks Pony, for keeping us informed... I continue to have faith!

Hank
be sure to send Thanks :up: to the engineers who are working so hard on this and getting real progress when it counts. :)
TiVoPony said:
We've identified a potential fix for the issues some of you have experienced with Scientific Atlanta CableCards, and it's testing very well in beta. It's a change that needs to soak in testing for a bit yet (to set expectations, we're looking at minimum a couple of weeks). So far, so good though.
Just curious if this potential fix would apply to the Series 3 as well as TiVoHD. I don't have a huge pixelation problem with my SA cablecards, but I would be interested if it helps with some of the problems on that platform as well...
ZeoTiVo said:
be sure to send Thanks :up: to the engineers who are working so hard on this and getting real progress when it counts. :)
Being a software developer, I can appreciate that these kinds of issues are REALLY tough to diagnose. Finding a consistent scenario to reproduce the problem can take forever. What can make it worse, is that when you use a version of the software with instrumentation to catch/log the problem, sometimes the problem will go away :eek: since the timing and memory layout isn't quite the same. And when you think you have the fix, you just have to let it age for a while in testing, like a fine red wine :)
TiVoPony said:
Hey guys, another update regarding the progress being made.

We've identified a potential fix for the issues some of you have experienced with Scientific Atlanta CableCards, and it's testing very well in beta. It's a change that needs to soak in testing for a bit yet (to set expectations, we're looking at minimum a couple of weeks). So far, so good though.

Again, it appears that a software update will resolve the issue. I'll keep you posted when the new update is ready.

Thanks again,
Pony
Is this a fix that can be refit for the Series 3 as well? Many here are experiencing macroblocking using SA cable cards with the S3 including me!
CharlesH said:
Being a software developer, I can appreciate that these kinds of issues are REALLY tough to diagnose. Finding a consistent scenario to reproduce the problem can take forever. What can make it worse, is that when you use a version of the software with instrumentation to catch/log the problem, sometimes the problem will go away :eek: since the timing and memory layout isn't quite the same. And when you think you have the fix, you just have to let it age for a while in testing, like a fine red wine :)
just to clarify to be sure, my post was a sincere thnaks and not a sarcastic one. For the reasons Charles list I know the engineers are working very hard to produce this kind of progress
ZeoTiVo said:
just to clarify to be sure, that was a sincere thanks and not a sarcastic one.
Absolutely sincere. I've been in computer science/software development for over 30 years, and can relate to these kinds of problems.
Just a little reassurance for anyone who might still be experiencing picture quality issues.

In December, I'll have been a TiVo customer for 5 years. In that time, I've seen TiVo address several issues and work diligently to resolve them. Unfortunately, stuff happens. Anything software-based is going to have some degree of issues with drivers and coding. But I feel completely safe in saying that TiVo will resolve any outstanding issues with the software.

And we're fortunate that TiVo employees actually post here from time to time - they don't have to. I own many other products where the support staff doesn't participate in product forums, and there's no way to put a "face" with a name.

So yeah, everyone keep the faith - it'll be ok.

I have no stake in TiVo other than the equipment I own. And I don't consider myself a "fanboy" or anything, just someone who's had pretty good luck with a damn fine product. :)
See less See more
I'll be eagerly waiting for the update. And I'm ready to be a beta tester if called upon! I get MBing every minute or two on my SA cable cards.
Thank you Pony! I sincerely appreciate the update(s) here on the forum. The THD is a kicka** product, and this fix will make the wait worthwhile.

-Matt
<paging Chimpware>: You still here? It's always darkest before the dawn, man. :)
I am here, and hoping the same as many that this works. Last 7 days for me, but I had my hopes up before and they were crushed. I have kept my tongue as not too many people were intersted in what I was saying.

It's not fixed yet, but I hope they get it...
Thanks for the update Pony! You have my express written consent to shoot the beta to my box right now!

My first big TV "event" is September 9th - The U.S. Open Men's Final and the premiere of Curb Your Enthusiasm. Let's shoot for that date as the target for the fix. ;)
TiVotion said:
Just a little reassurance for anyone who might still be experiencing picture quality issues.

In December, I'll have been a TiVo customer for 5 years. In that time, I've seen TiVo address several issues and work diligently to resolve them. Unfortunately, stuff happens. Anything software-based is going to have some degree of issues with drivers and coding. But I feel completely safe in saying that TiVo will resolve any outstanding issues with the software.

And we're fortunate that TiVo employees actually post here from time to time - they don't have to. I own many other products where the support staff doesn't participate in product forums, and there's no way to put a "face" with a name.

So yeah, everyone keep the faith - it'll be ok.

I have no stake in TiVo other than the equipment I own. And I don't consider myself a "fanboy" or anything, just someone who's had pretty good luck with a damn fine product. :)
+1 :up:

Your post sums it up quite well.

Given Tivo's track record, I really don't understand all the Chicken Little posts about various issues.

Yes, it would be nice if they were all fixed before release, but that's not always practical.

(and, thanks Pony!)
Chimpware said:
I am here, and hoping the same as many that this works. Last 7 days for me, but I had my hopes up before and they were crushed. I have kept my tongue as not too many people were intersted in what I was saying.
It's not that anyone wasn't interested, it's just that you didn't have anything new to say. :)

Glad to see you haven't given up. I hope you will post your experiences after the fix is released.
is this SA fix for pixelation/macroblocking (viewing quality issues) or is it for actually tuning in channels( which I'm having trouble with)?
jfh3 said:
It's not that anyone wasn't interested, it's just that you didn't have anything new to say. :)

Glad to see you haven't given up. I hope you will post your experiences after the fix is released.
Always posted new information, just no new positive results, and then refused to let the fanboys beat me down ;)
Chimpware said:
Always posted new information, just no new positive results, and then refused to let the fanboys beat me down ;)
Except that no one was trying to beat you down ... just advocating a little patience and trying to discourage folks from falling into the Chicken Little syndrome because history has shown that Tivo would likely release a fix relatively quickly ... much as the initial post in this thread indicates. ;)
Thanks for the latest info Pony. Am curious why the problems seem to be more related with the SA cards, hum...


Now if you'd say there is an software patch to enable the SATA port, that would make my day....

How soon after the Series 3 Tivo of last September 17th, was there a software update that enabled the SATA port on that model?
1 - 20 of 84 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top