I've posted about this issue before. I was hoping 6.3e would fix, but no.
This is easy to recreate, and yes I've deleted it, rebooted, and re-added it, moved it to #1 on the season pass list, no luck, so let's not go there.
The problem is this:
I enter in a keyword (my team's name) when creating a wishlist, then specify the Sports category and Football as the subcategory.
I then can see that there are upcoming programs, and these are indeed the programs that I want. This tells me I'm using good keywords. I then set it to autorecord, and... and... NADA. Nothing ever shows up on the To-Do list or on the Recording History. None of the shows in the upcoming programs are ever selected.
Now, it didn't used to be this way, this used to work perfectly a few years ago, and it's gotten to be totally useless since then.
What's up with this? Tivo people, are you out there? Where do I file a bug report?