TiVo Community Forum banner
1 - 20 of 84 Posts

·
Member
Joined
·
2,445 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Nice, very nice. I was getting somewhat disappointed in the Carver being Quentin, then bam. I wonder if the storyline will come back in the future.

The Matt/Cherry ending didn't seem to tie up as nicely.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
288 Posts
I was just annoyed by the "added twist", which explained nothing that wasn't explained by the first level of revelation. Plus: which doctor declared him dead without noticing that he was wearing a vest? And when they went up to Maine because they were "obsessive-compulsive", was that before or after Quentin's body disappeared from the morgue, which many people might find suspicious?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
39 Posts
Great! I loved it! The Carver was a little to easy but I liked the added twist they threw in, the twist kept me from being totally disappointed in what I saw was an obvious guess at who the Carver was.

Matt's story wasn't tied as nice though.

I'm glad that Sean and Julia are back together and I really hope it lasts. I wonder what the test results showed for her baby or did I miss something?

One huge inconsistency that really bugged me was how they shot the Matt and crazy father scenes in a basement. Anyone from FL and Miami knows that FL, and Miami especially, is way to flat to have any houses with basements. The basement would be built under sea level. I'm a little miffed that the writers didn't know better.

Otherwise I thought it was great and will miss this show for another year.
 

·
Wild Hair
Joined
·
5,095 Posts
Keith_R90210 said:
One huge inconsistency that really bugged me was how they shot the Matt and crazy father scenes in a basement. Anyone from FL and Miami knows that FL, and Miami especially, is way to flat to have any houses with basements. The basement would be built under sea level. I'm a little miffed that the writers didn't know better.
Maybe this house is raised up. From the outside it looks like a Two story house but the stairs from outside bring you to the second story. Then you go down sstairs back to ground level.

Hey I don't know it could happen
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,183 Posts
Very satisfying. I liked it.

I did call Kit as the sister when she was staring out the window in her office explaining it to Troy & Christian. But then when she said the sister was dead I thought "oh, guess she's not the sister after all". But then as soon as Quentin 'woke up' I knew it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
298 Posts
Keith_R90210 said:
I'm glad that Sean and Julia are back together and I really hope it lasts. I wonder what the test results showed for her baby or did I miss something?
Don't hold your breath. The test results were obviously not good - Julia cannot bring herself to terminate the pregnancy and cannot see raising a child with challenges on her own, so she's back with Sean - Even though it's the last thing she wants.

Sidenote:

Last scene, with Matt "coming home" WHERE THE FREAK IS THE DAUGHTER????
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
238 Posts
Artfreak said:
Don't hold your breath. The test results were obviously not good - Julia cannot bring herself to terminate the pregnancy and cannot see raising a child with challenges on her own, so she's back with Sean - Even though it's the last thing she wants.
I got the same vibe from the look in her eyes when they were hugging at the end. She knows the baby is not going to be 100% healthy and she wants Sean close to lean on and/or blame.
 

·
Go Pats
Joined
·
44,199 Posts
Artfreak said:
Don't hold your breath. The test results were obviously not good - Julia cannot bring herself to terminate the pregnancy and cannot see raising a child with challenges on her own, so she's back with Sean - Even though it's the last thing she wants.

Sidenote:

Last scene, with Matt "coming home" WHERE THE FREAK IS THE DAUGHTER????
Do you mean the Nazi daughter of the dead guy, or the middle school daughter of Sean? Cause she was there
 

·
tciddAweDehT
Joined
·
3,536 Posts
One thing I'm confused about...

So Quentin lacks male genetalia...that was easy enough to hide at the frat party (pay a drunk girl to pretend), and easy enough when he was raping people as the Carver (fully dressed to hide the prosthetic straps). What about when he was screwing the military guy in the recovery room? If I remember correctly, he was screwing the military guy, and they were both naked. How did he hide his lack of a member then?

All in all, I was disappointed in Quentin being the Carver, but the writers really redeamed themselves with the whole backstory. Hopefully this is the last we hear of the Carver, and the show can get back to it's roots.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
16,197 Posts
I liked Rhona's 'American' accent when she was poolside in Malaga. Very hot!
Her bathing suit coulda been a little more revealing please.

ANNNNND: So how did Quentin and Julia whip up a batch of chowder in the hot tub?
 

·
Irish-Im!
Joined
·
84 Posts
TheDewAddict said:
One thing I'm confused about...

So Quentin lacks male genetalia...that was easy enough to hide at the frat party (pay a drunk girl to pretend), and easy enough when he was raping people as the Carver (fully dressed to hide the prosthetic straps). What about when he was screwing the military guy in the recovery room? If I remember correctly, he was screwing the military guy, and they were both naked. How did he hide his lack of a member then?

All in all, I was disappointed in Quentin being the Carver, but the writers really redeamed themselves with the whole backstory. Hopefully this is the last we hear of the Carver, and the show can get back to it's roots.
I thought it was Quentin getting it from the soldier boy.....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
298 Posts
Amnesia said:
She was there! We saw her.
See...They've not used her so much that when she is there, I don't see her!

THEDEWADDICT said:
One thing I'm confused about...

So Quentin lacks male genetalia...that was easy enough to hide at the frat party (pay a drunk girl to pretend), and easy enough when he was raping people as the Carver (fully dressed to hide the prosthetic straps). What about when he was screwing the military guy in the recovery room? If I remember correctly, he was screwing the military guy, and they were both naked. How did he hide his lack of a member then?
YES! I told Ekims as this was unfolding, "That cop is a pretty horrible "special" cop! It's conceivable for Liz to wear a strap on but not Quentin?"

Now I know why she was sooo....lame.

Not sure how I feel about it all. I know I don't want the Carver to creep up in any future shows.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,144 Posts
I gotta admit I was disappointed in the general conclusion. Quentin (and even the Kit angle) was too predictable. I was hoping, for a brief second, that after we saw the OB/GYN doctor carved that it might have been Julia (which would have been far more satisfying), but alas, no. I will say I was watching the back-and-forth between the neo-Nazi dad and Quentin working his magic on Sean and Christian with mouth agape; I just wish they had taken it a little further to shock us all (Matt is forced to castrate himself; Christian mutilates his own hand, etc.).

Of course, that probably just means I'm sick and twisted.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,144 Posts
Artfreak said:
YES! I told Ekims as this was unfolding, "That cop is a pretty horrible "special" cop! It's conceivable for Liz to wear a strap on but not Quentin?"
Yes, it's conceivable, but by that point Quentin had been all but eliminated from consideration. It was the sorority girls who revealed that the Carver was using a strap-on, and when that happened the police immediately rushed to Quentin's place, where they found him to be yet another victim.
 
1 - 20 of 84 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top