You need the units on the same account, at very least, and be reasonably active.
If you want to buy an S3 after you buy a Tivo-HD, you will have to start another commitment on it to get the rebate, or forfeit the rebate to replace the TiVoHD.
You will have to re-image the old S3 drive to the TiVoHD image.
If you want to buy an S3 after you buy a Tivo-HD, you will have to start another commitment on it to get the rebate, or forfeit the rebate to replace the TiVoHD.
You will have to re-image the old S3 drive to the TiVoHD image.