TiVo Community Forum banner
1 - 20 of 38 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm just curious how long people are planning on holding out on "upgrading" their 10-250s. For me right now the only thing I'm missing out on is the local HDs which isn't a big deal, but if the upcoming HD programming requires a new box I'm going to be very sad to lose the Tivo interface. I might just wait until they die or they force me to switch.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
82 Posts
Zor said:
I'm just curious how long people are planning on holding out on "upgrading" their 10-250s. For me right now the only thing I'm missing out on is the local HDs which isn't a big deal, but if the upcoming HD programming requires a new box I'm going to be very sad to lose the Tivo interface. I might just wait until they die or they force me to switch.
My attitude is "As long as it works, and I'm not missing out on large chunks of content, I'm happy." I assume that at some point, it will either fail, or no longer be able to tune significant content, (as MPEG4 begins to prevail), and that's when it will be time to move on. I've got about a year left on my commitment to DirecTV. When that's up, I'm considering a jump to Comcast...but that's down the road.

-Mark
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,798 Posts
Until DTV no longer sends the programming :)

I'm installing 2 HR20's in 2 weeks, but am keeping my existing 2 HR10's until they are paperweights. Then I'll toss.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
I don't have a 10-250, I have the one circa 2001.

The minute DirecTV drops Tivo, I'll drop them. The only reason I even watch TV is because of TiVo.

In fact, if I upgrade to a flatscreen TV, I'll drop DirecTV at the same time, because their current HD-DVR sucks from what I've seen on their website.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
64 Posts
Same here. I've learned with anything that you buy that's electronic, it's only the current "Fad" until something else comes out that's either better, or the product you just spent a fortune on is replaced with it's "Ultra, new improved, updated cousin! I went nuts to get the HR-10 and ended up getting it for under $20 when some people paid in excess of $1000 for the same thing. Now, the hardware and software are different on these newer units and they can handle the new MPEG4. As long as my HR-10 works I can wait for another sweet deal from DirecTV and try to get this newer receiver for $20 again. Because as soon as I get it, there will definitely be posts on these forums on some new receiver that will be coming out and the receiver that just arrived at my door will now be the old, outdated one that people will be selling for $50 on e-bay! :) Thank God that technology doesn't stand still, but I for one still look at my HR-10 and say to myself "I sure am glad that I didn't spend $1000 on that thing", because I spend enough on programming from DirecTV....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
mbobak said:
My attitude is "As long as it works, and I'm not missing out on large chunks of content, I'm happy." I assume that at some point, it will either fail, or no longer be able to tune significant content, (as MPEG4 begins to prevail), and that's when it will be time to move on. I've got about a year left on my commitment to DirecTV. When that's up, I'm considering a jump to Comcast...but that's down the road.

-Mark
If cable was a good option then I'd consider it (go go Series 3). But I'm definitely locked into DTV as long as they have the Sunday ticket. My brother has the HR20 and every time I use it I want to throw the remote through the tv.
 

·
Just hangin'
Joined
·
30,958 Posts
I may have to, at some point in time, "upgrade" to the HR20, but that doesn't mean I'll give up the HR10. As I've mentioned in any number of other threads, the HR10 will continue to work just fine for SD and OTA HD.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
31 Posts
You may want to consider selling your HR10(s) now while they still hold some value. Prices for used HR10s on eBay have dropped considerably over the last few months.

Can't hurt to call D* now and see what kind of deal they'll give you on the HR20. If it's decent, I'd suggest taking it and selling the HR10 while you still can.
 

·
TiVoted TiVo User
Joined
·
5,612 Posts
My HR10 is still much more reliable at recording programs than my HR20. When the HR20 can get as reliable as the HR10 then I will consider retiring my HR10.
 

·
Drew != Drawn
Joined
·
4,862 Posts
When the HR10 can no longer receive HD signals from DIRECTV, I'll retire my HDVR2s and use my HR10s as SD receivers.
 

·
Tivo User
Joined
·
2,507 Posts
It will always receive HD signals. OTA is the best HD and it's free.

drew2k said:
When the HR10 can no longer receive HD signals, I'll retire my HDVR2s and use my HR10s as SD receivers.
 

·
Drew != Drawn
Joined
·
4,862 Posts
magnus said:
It will always receive HD signals. OTA is the best HD and it's free.
In my head I was referring to the DIRECTV HD signals. :p

See, here's proof from another post of mine tonight:

drew2k said:
To the OP: Once my HR10s can no longer receive HD signals from DIRECTV, I plan to retire my SD HDVR2s and run my HR10s as SD DIRECTV DVRs. They have larger drives than the HDVR2s, so they can record more SD programs, and I can use them on any TV in the house.
Nevertheless, I'll fix my earlier post here to avoid confusion. :)
 

·
HD evangelist
Joined
·
3,604 Posts
Not to be a pessimist (maybe a realist) but I think there may be a good chance that after the Tivo agreement expires with DTV in 2010 that DTV may deauthorize all HR10s, meaning that they would not get OTA either. Maybe not under Liberty/Malone.

Of course there is also the chance that a HR10 deauthorized by DTV could be reauthorized by Tivo.

My intent is to keep all 3 of mine going until there is content I want in M4, which could be a year from now or more. At that point I might grudgingly allow one to be replaced with whatever the best POS DTV has going at the time might be (gulp!) :eek: . But I'll replace HDDs and power supplies in them until then, or until repair becomes impractical.

I am also hoping that Cox allows S3's or maybe even DTV reups with Tivo for a M4 DTivo (a lot could happen in a year or two).

It also wouldn't be a bad thing if Apple bought Tivo and allowed the software to run under OSX, which might mean a home-grown Mac DVR platform could emerge. I'd buy into that.
 

·
Tivo User
Joined
·
2,507 Posts
That would just plain SUCK and at the same time not surprise me.

TyroneShoes said:
Not to be a pessimist (maybe a realist) but I think there may be a good chance that after the Tivo agreement expires with DTV in 2010 that DTV may deauthorize all HR10s, meaning that they would not get OTA either. Maybe not under Liberty/Malone.
 

·
Cracker Soul
Joined
·
2,492 Posts
I'll probably replace my HR10 and DirecTV with a TiVo S3 and WOW cable by the first week of September. I was going wait until the end of the year when my commitment is up, but I don't want to split football or the new fall season across DVRs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
318 Posts
Well I use the hr10-250 in my bedroom, and as much as I flip back and forth between tuners, the tivo aint going away any time soon. ONLY, and I mean ONLY if the tivo costs me some HD channels in MPG 4 that I want would be the only reason Id switch out the tivo from the bedroom. Lack of dual live buffers just KILLS me at night when I like to switch back nd forth between CNN and ESPN, then I can just zoom through the commercials. Cant do that with the hr20.

After getting used to the tivo ability to switch between 2 tuners, not sure how anyone could go back to 1 tuner. It would be comparable to having a color TV for 6 months and than it being taken away and replaced by a black and white.
 

·
Poster of News
Joined
·
35,621 Posts
jennifer said:
Until DTV no longer sends the programming :)

I'm installing 2 HR20's in 2 weeks, but am keeping my existing 2 HR10's until they are paperweights. Then I'll toss.
more tuners and storage = more fun and options! I agree. I'll pay the 5/month for the hr20 (or maybe wait for the 21 lol) as long as i get it close to free in the next year or so. until i have more than 2 programs needing to be recorded for the new HD, my solution will be perfect for years go come.

Also note that a lot of these new stations coming online repeat stuff regularly. So we can keep our OTA on hdtivo and run the new mpeg4 stuff on HR20 and things will just be fine.
 

·
Done.
Joined
·
3,105 Posts
TyroneShoes said:
Not to be a pessimist (maybe a realist) but I think there may be a good chance that after the Tivo agreement expires with DTV in 2010 that DTV may deauthorize all HR10s, meaning that they would not get OTA either.
I really doubt that. Ultimate TV DVRs are still working just fine many years after the last one was sold.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
magnus said:
It will always receive HD signals. OTA is the best HD and it's free.
mine never had a good enough tuner to recieve half the OTA channels my TV would recieve.
so the ability to use Tivo with my locals never worked for me
 
1 - 20 of 38 Posts
Top