TiVo Community Forum banner
1 - 20 of 123 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm considering the jump to HiDefinition...I'm currently a DirecTivo user on a 50" "analog" 4:3 TV.

I've been intending on going with D*'s MPEG4 solution when available, but doing some homework here...it seems that Comcast (Detroit area) may have the better package, both in terms of cost and Picture Quality.

I don't want to HiJack a DirecTv forum to talk Comcast...so if their is a more appropriate forum, please direct me.

I'd like to hear from converts...those that have recently left DirecTv for Comcast...Pros and Cons of switching...Problems you've had with audio drop-outs, or similar service-related concerns...

Thanks
 

·
What happened, TiVo?
Joined
·
2,219 Posts
If you can get all your locals from Comcast, and a decent HD package, you should go with Comcast

Or wait a year to see what DirecTV does.

If I were making the decision now, I would definitely drop DirecTV. But I've got two HD Tivo's I need to accrue.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
JeffGrimes said:
I'm considering the jump to HiDefinition...I'm currently a DirecTivo user on a 50" "analog" 4:3 TV.

I've been intending on going with D*'s MPEG4 solution when available, but doing some homework here...it seems that Comcast (Detroit area) may have the better package, both in terms of cost and Picture Quality.

I don't want to HiJack a DirecTv forum to talk Comcast...so if their is a more appropriate forum, please direct me.

I'd like to hear from converts...those that have recently left DirecTv for Comcast...Pros and Cons of switching...Problems you've had with audio drop-outs, or similar service-related concerns...

Thanks
Technically, this is an HDTV Tivo Powered DVR forum, so I think these conversations concerning Comcast should be welcome since Tivo and Comcast will be hand in hand eventually (not that anyone has said we shouldn't talk Comcast, but still...)

Dropping my Directv (and my Tivo *sniff*) tomorrow for the Comcast HD DVR in Macomb, MI. I'll let you know how it goes.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
34 Posts
Scheduled the install for Comcast next Saturday in Dallas. Problem in Dallas is that it's an old cable system and I won't have the dual tuner feature with the PVR.

On the positive side I am getting the full package from Comcast with Internet for 69.95 a month for a year. Currently paying DirecTv 90.00 for just satellite.

I figured I could always come back if I don't like it and will be suspending my DirecTv account.
 

·
Coming and going
Joined
·
2,824 Posts
I have comcast HD and have been very pleased... in my area we have:

PBS, CBS, ABC, NBC, ESPN, DISCOVERY, FOX, UPN, WB, HBO, SHOWTIME, CINEMAX, STARZ, INHD1, INHD2

There may be one or two more that I don't remember.... I would definetly recommend it and I have had no problems with any of those channels so far... over 1 year in with HD.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Comcast is offering incredible deals for the first year. I am reluctant to switch because of what will happen to my bill after the first year. In Maryland, digital cable (basic) is $64.95 per month. The DVR fee is $9.95 per month. HD fee is $5.00 per month. This is $80.00/month with only one DVR that has a hard drive half the size of the HD-Tivo.

We have three Tivo's (one HD) and you can't beat the $4.99 Tivo fee for unlimited Tivo's on D*.

Scott
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
I'm scheduled for a digital cable installation from Comcast one week from today in the NW burbs of Chicago. My HD DirecTiVo has worked flawlessly, unlike some other people's, but I am tired of the lack of urgency to offer more HD from DirecTV. I already get all my OTA locals in HD, so the big push to get locals in HD doesn't effect me. Plus, I'm saving over 50 bucks a months to get Comcast's top-of-the-line package compared to DirecTV's Premier.

I plan to use both systems for a month and keep whichever I like best. If they are close, I will probably keep the Comcast and save the money.
 

·
Registered Offender
Joined
·
1,388 Posts
Wow, that's amazing that you're going to save $.

Here in the Northern Chicago burbs, I just called Comcast a few days ago. Right now I have D* Total Choice Plus w/locals and HBO. I have a total of five receivers, all of them DTivos (one is in my son's semitruck). I called up asking for a price on something similar: four digital outlets, all with DVRs. I also asked for HD as a separate cost (since I haven't yet added HD to D*, although I'm getting ready to).

The monthly cost (without HD) was $40/month higher./ For one less outlet.

Can't justify that, no way, no how.

Most of this, I suspect, is the DVR leasing fees of $9.95/box (as opposed to D*s DVR fee of $4.95 flat).
 

·
Sci-Fi Junkie
Joined
·
36,325 Posts
I just moved to Comcast. No real problems so far. The DVR does funny stuff sometimes but I have had plenty of problems with my DirecTivo as well. Overall, my costs are the same or less than D* (I am actually paying more but getting a LOT more so I consider it a wash). The price is good for 12-16 months. At that time, I can look out there and see what is available. D* will probably offer me something good to leave, Comcast will probably offer me something to stay.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
I have used both the Directv HR10-250 and the Comcast Motorola 6412. In terms of HD content and High Definition PQ, the Comcast, at least in my neighborhood, is superior to D*. Actually, I have recently terminated D* and use two 6412's that provide four tuners and 240 gig hard drive space. I use one DVR for HD series recordings and the other for SD recordings. I do need to place a shield on one of the DVRs to prevent the remote from interacting with both at the same time. So far, all of the recordings occur as scheduled, and I simply swith the shield from one DVR to the other when I want to watch a scheduled recording. The Comcast DVR is not a Tivo, but the trade-off is a better HD picture and all of the network HD broadcasts. Comcast has indicated that they plan to offer a Tivo option in March 2006.

In terms of usability, The Comcast Motorola 6412 has two tuners, series or individual recording options, first run only etc. It uses the grid for scheduling programs and has about two weeks of scheduled programs on the grid. The 6412 allows the user to check and cancel scheduled recordings (a to do list), and change the order of scheduled recordings to indicate your preference if a schedule conflict occurs. Comcast does offer the 30 second skip. In other words, in terms of the basic DVR operations it offers everything that Tivo offers and operates much more quickly.

The Tivo HR10-250 has a more friendly user interface, and a much better conflict resolution system. For example, if there is a conflict with a requested recording, Tivo will seek to find another broadcast time to record the requested program. Comcast does not offer this option. In addition, of course, Tivo offers the wish list, suggestions, and an easier system and several options for finding programs to record (name, channel or time).

The major problems with the Comcast 6412 is hard drive space (120 gig). You are limited to about 14 hours of HD programs/50 hours of SD programs. I do use two 6412's that helps with the space problem. The second problem is that Comcast does not have Tivo, although they indicate that they plan to offer that option in March, 2006.

In sum, there is no perfect solution at this point. I simply opted for the better PQ and more HD content offered by Comcast. D* may offer a better solution with the HMC in 2006, and/or Comcast with Tivo and SATA enabled (external hard drive) may offer a better solution in 2006.
 

·
Sci-Fi Junkie
Joined
·
36,325 Posts
DuffMan said:
For those of you who have recently had your comcast install, a quick question: did the installer use an HDMI cable for the tv hookup or component video?
Component. The installation was a month or so ago. I keep thinking about changing but I have heard that many people have had problems with it and that the change in PQ is not that much, if at all.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13 Posts
DuffMan said:
For those of you who have recently had your comcast install, a quick question: did the installer use an HDMI cable for the tv hookup or component video?
I had Comcast installed this past Tuesday and I'm in the process of comparing D* HD to Comcast's. To me, the D* picture is superior on my plasma. Although I'm using hdmi with D* and component (which the installer used) with Comcast, the picture quality is night and day. It's to the point that if I'm switching between ESPN HD on D* and Comcast and leave the room, when I return, I can look at the picture and tell if I left the TV on D* or Comcast.

When I compared hdmi and component with my D* equipment only, I could not see this much of a difference in picture quality. This is a big surprise to me, since everyone has been saying that Comcast's picture quality is superior to D*.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Sherman67:
Your response to the PQ on D* and Comcast is not unusual. The Comcast PQ, channel lineup, and SD/HD varies considerably depending on where you live, type of cable, ADS or analog, wiring, number of splitters etc. All you can do is simply do what you did. Namely, you compare the Comcast and D* and make the best choice based on PQ, cost, lineup etc. There is no magic answer that can be applied to every circumstance.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
Sherman67 said:
I had Comcast installed this past Tuesday and I'm in the process of comparing D* HD to Comcast's. To me, the D* picture is superior on my plasma. Although I'm using hdmi with D* and component (which the installer used) with Comcast, the picture quality is night and day. It's to the point that if I'm switching between ESPN HD on D* and Comcast and leave the room, when I return, I can look at the picture and tell if I left the TV on D* or Comcast.

When I compared hdmi and component with my D* equipment only, I could not see this much of a difference in picture quality. This is a big surprise to me, since everyone has been saying that Comcast's picture quality is superior to D*.
Sherman, you have to be careful hear...While it would be hopefull that every consumer-electronic-grade video device output a perfectly calibrated signal (i.e. all the same) we know it not to be true.

My point/comment/question is: Did you compare the picture quality after "calibrating" each source with Avia or similar? Comcast could just be sending a lower contrast or less "bright" image...making it look duller. Simply adjusting the brightess or contrast could make a difference.

I'm asking/stating, because I would suspect that D* compresses even their HiDef signal, whereas Comcast does not (I believe).

I know Locals in SD over D* are bloody-awefull. I mean, a very clean image, no ditial artifacts or noise...but very "soft".

That, and Hi Def are the reasons I'm considering the switch.
 
1 - 20 of 123 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top