TiVo Community Forum banner
1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
TDL shepherd
Joined
·
17,365 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
In case there might be anyone in the neighborhood wanting to hammer out issues of privacy surrounding Smart Home devices (Alexa, Google Home, etc), or other technologies, as you see fit. Fill 'er up.

Appetizers to get you started...

Woman says her Amazon device recorded private conversation, sent it out to random contact (h/t @bobfrank)
Amazon confirms that Echo device secretly shared user's private audio [Updated] (h/t @morac)

Alexa, go ahead and hand over recordings in murder case - CNN (h/t @Mikeguy)

A Cell Network Flaw Lets Hackers Drain Bank Accounts. Here's How to Fix It (h/t @morac)
 

·
I'm Feeling Blue
Joined
·
303 Posts
Alexa listens to everything. It's a concern, but you can unplug the heifer when you're not using her. Just remember that anything you say while she's in the room is available to anyone at Amazon and any authority that may be around now, or in the future.
Oh dear lord ... I think I'm going to make some popcorn. Looks like this one could be quite entertaining. :)o_O
 

·
Cranky old novice
Joined
·
9,425 Posts
But still not quite as interesting as @gigaquad's avatar and screen name.:p

Is that a "cat-faced chick" or am I seeing things?:confused:
Maybe it's Henny Penny, telling us the [privacy] sky is falling. :D

Judging by the ridiculous little things so many people choose to argue about, be insulted by, or worry about these days, we're turning into a society of effete idiots.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
15,966 Posts
To be honest, I'm not even looking forward to having to replace another tv because, from what I'm seeing, it looks like the new ones now are pretty much all smart tvs. Nothing against it. I like technology, too, but I have my Tivos and my Roku3, blu-ray, etc, and don't need or even want a 'smart' tv. There is enough stuff that can go wrong with something and I feel like the more features they jam into a single unit, the more there is to go wrong. Now, I'm likely wrong in that assessment but, seriously, I'm fine with a tv that is more stupid than I. :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,081 Posts
It's important that people understand how Alexa (or Siri or Google Home or Cortana or...) works before installing an Alexa enabled device. It's important that people understand how these devices can work as well. The fact is that any device with a microphone, an operating system, and an internet connection can be programmed or operated to capture audio and send it somewhere else. If this concerns you, do not use these devices. Frankly, I do not find the Alexa story about the sent conversation credible -- just too many coincidences. I would have to hear the conversation before I accept the scenario. BUT there is no doubt in my mind that such things can be done deliberately. In fact, in 2010, a school district in Pennsylvania was sued over just such a possibility. I do not recall the outcome of the suit, but...

An assistant principal at Harriton later confirmed that the district could remotely activate the webcam in students' laptops. "Michael Robbins thereafter verified, through [Assistant Principal] Ms. Matsko, that the school district in fact has the ability to remotely activate the webcam contained in a student's personal laptop computer issued by the school district at any time it chose and to view and capture whatever images were in front of the webcam, all without the knowledge, permission or authorization of any persons then and there using the laptop computer," the lawsuit stated.

Most laptops and a lot of devices come with capable hardware and the bad guys don't all wear black hats these days, so assume nothing about privacy.

No one's talking about the other privacy issue, but how many devices have you shared your wireless password with? What else do you use that password for? What might someone on your home network find that could be of concern (starting with all those cameras and microphones.

(Sage advice: put all those devices on a guest network with an SSID and password which are different than your home network. If you have the energy and time, restrict your wireless network to specific mac addresses.)

Then there is the home computer -- the portal to your universe. Back around the turn of the century (doesn't that sound funny?) I ran a customer support chat channel for Prodigy (anyone remember Prodigy?) which was frequented by disruptive people with funny screen names. One of the women in the chat room 'followed' one of the bad guys back to their cave and warned that she knew who they were, what they did, and would have their channel shut down if they continued to disrupt ours. The next morning she received an anonymous email with a list of all the files on her PC. That was in the 90s.

People have been tapping phone lines for a century and listening in on cell phone calls since the 70s.

So there is a vulnerability. What is the risk? You buy a device. Someone is interested in listening to or watching you. You say or do things which could be used to harm you. Define 'harm' for you and determine your threshold for risk, then decide if you want devices listening to you.

BTW, QVC has the Show plus a smart plug for $140 this weekend. I have five of these. Not too worried about people hearing or seeing what goes on in my home and really enjoy the convenience of automation.
 

·
Cranky old novice
Joined
·
9,425 Posts
It's important that people understand how Alexa (or Siri or Google Home or Cortana or...) works before installing an Alexa enabled device. It's important that people understand how these devices can work as well. The fact is that any device with a microphone, an operating system, and an internet connection can be programmed or operated to capture audio and send it somewhere else. If this concerns you, do not use these devices. ...........
......................
So there is a vulnerability. What is the risk? You buy a device. Someone is interested in listening to or watching you. You say or do things which could be used to harm you. Define 'harm' for you and determine your threshold for risk, then decide if you want devices listening to you.
............
I wouldn't disagree with this in general but I think, regarding Alexa in particular, it tends too much toward fostoring paranoia. If just moderate attention is paid to Router and WiFi security and preventing physical access by untrusted strangers, the odds of someone either progamming or operating Alexa to eavesdrop are miniscule. If you disagree, please spell out the details.
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top