We have two TiVos in our household - an old S2 which has finally died after being on life support for a couple of years, and an HD. Both have Lifetime subscriptions. I'm looking at purchasing a new Premiere w/Lifetime, and relegating the HD to the guest room which used to house the S2. However, because the S2 was our original unit and the HD was purchased at an MSD discount, the S2 is the anchor unit for our MSD, and since it's no longer active, I'm no longer seeing discounts on either hardware or subscriptions on the TiVo site. So, my dilemma is whether to toss Weaknees $150 to resurrect the old S2, which would basically just sit in a corner idling and making regular connections to TiVo HQ in order to retain our MSD, or whether I should just put it on eBay as-is and pay full whack for a new Premiere which would then become the anchor for a new MSD if we were to purchase another down the track. Whaddyall think?