So, these new options kinda confuse me. I currently have a Tivo HD and Tivo Premiere. I pay $12.95+$9.95 monthly. I'm about to move, so it's time to review my Tivo service. I'm debating if I should switch the Premiere to Lifetime for $499 or not. For that matter, I'm wondering if I should just upgrade to a second premiere and retire the HD for the same price ($399+$99). I believe that my current plan will last until 2013 (I bought the premiere in August and had them fix my multi-discount a few months later when it got confused). $500-$1000 is hard to swallow, even if it does make sense over three years. The question is, what makes the most sense?