Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'TiVo Coffee House - TiVo Discussion' started by innocentfreak, May 9, 2011.
most likely because tivo abandoned the S3's when the premiers came out.
At least one - me. I have DSL and am not interested in switching. I doubt if I am alone in that either.
Exactly. It's not that it can't be done, just that it won't be done.
I dont think you are alone, I think there are about another nine of you in the whole US. LOL.
Joking aside and serious question- why do you get DSL and not buy bundle from comcast?
Is DSL that much cheaper in your then the upcharge to add comcast internet to your tv package?
In my neck of the woods there's just no combination that can beat comcast's triple play. But i realize comcast pricing various all over. (My local comcast system competes directly with FIOS for much of it's footprint so that may be why my pricing and service is so good on comcast.)
I cancelled my voice line last year, so no need for triple play. I've had more problems with cable than I've ever had with phone line. I'm actually on u-verse internet currently at a reduced rate anyway so converting is not at option at this time anyway. I've been thinking about totally cancelling cable and going to OTA. Need more reasons?
I wasn't going to bring this up but unless there is some technical reason for it, requiring cable internet to get On Demand may be a violation of FTC regulations.
I cancelled my landline phone a while back and then Comcast made me an offer such that it was cheaper for me to have the Triple Play, including a new landline phone, than it was for me not to have the phone. So now I have a landline phone again.
I wouldn't be at all surprised if there were, in fact, technical reasons why the S3 DVRs can't handle the XOD. There certainly are enough other features already that the S3 can't handle technically. Is anybody really suggesting that no new features should be added to the DVR unless they can be backward compatible to the S3s? There'd be a lot missing if TiVo followed that strategy.
Me two. FIOS is more reliable internet connection where I live. I have Comcast for TV.
Hope it is not a requirement but we shall see.
Not quite- all old units still get guide data.
Abandoning would have been what Moxi was considering before backtracking.
You are only talking about adding new features, which TiVo reps have noted many times are not available to older units due to the lack of hardware support for the software used in their current generation units. I imagine it would be like using an old slot 1 celeron to run handbrake- perhaps it could do it - but would not be a worthwhile experience.
I do. Probably will shift back to Comcast for broadband soon, but still on DSL for now.
The only technical reason I can think of for them to require their Internet service for the uplink is quality-of-service guarantees. On their own network, they can prioritize the uplink traffic to get the desired consistent response time. If it travels any part of the way off their network, then they cannot make any guarantees. Sort of like their phone service using dedicated routing on their network.
Other issues like security could be dealt with via VPN technology.
In my neighborhood, cable lines are ancient and overloaded. DSL just upgraded to fiber optic and can match advertised cable speeds up to 20 mbs and you actually get the speed you pay for instead of paying for 8 mbs and only getting 1-2 mbs. Unless I want to use the Internet in the middle of the night. Now I pay for 12 and almost always get 10-11 mbs speeds. All at a cheaper price too.
I would guess that this is less common, but tryin to explain why a few of us wouldn't take the cable broadband.
Yeah. I've gotten along this long w/o OD. If it requires cable internet, I'll continue to survive w/o it.
Glad to read this is coming. My triple play special ends in 5 months and I'll have a decision to make. Dump phone & TV and go OTA & Internet streaming or just downgrade a bit.
I just want to clarify & understand something regarding this future "Comcast TiVo" with OnDemand. Will it be Comcast OnDemand on a commercially available TiVo (Premiere) that you buy in a store or online? Or will it be a Comcast issued Premiere box from a local office (that ultimately won't have Netflix or Hulu capability)?
I'm hoping the former. I recently got a Premiere from Best Buy. While I'm not a regular OnDemad user in the first place, I would still love to see this on my current retail Premiere unit. I always just chalked it up as a lost cause & the many features of TiVo that I use (Netflix, Pandora, pyTivo, MRV, etc.) outweigh having the OnDemand service instead, but I'll take IT ALL if possible.
If this becomes available in my area, I might even be more willing to swallow & pay the ridiculous $9.95 "digital outlet" fee Comcast is slapping me with each month for each cable card in my TiVo HDs ($30/month). My local office is refunding most of it each month, but its a pain to have to go through the nonsense. I would probably also just sell my Series 3 (lifetime) and get another Premiere since it requires 2 cable cards.
Yes, this is for retail TiVo Premiers.
Looks like you need both Comcast Xfinity cable and Internet to get the service.
Actually there is no confirmation yet that you will require to have Comcast Internet Service as well.
Some form of High Speed Internet will be required plus existing comcast CAble ACcount. Don't know if it might be similar to their online xfinity site where you just need a user id and password to access Online VOD Content.
According to this post (http://www.tivocommunity.com/tivo-vb/showthread.php?p=8984537#post8984537) by Dave Zatz, access to OnDemand will not require Internet from Comcast.
EARLY April. Assuming the schedule holds.
To me that says it'll be available in April in San Francisco. When it's available anywhere else is anyone's guess.