Advertisements Hi, I’m a long time Tivo user and unfortunately the place that I am moving to does not have Xfinity and has a contract for Directv only. With that being said I’m debating b/w a Tivo Edge or a Roku Ultra with a Tablo DVR. I currently have a 3TB Bolt that does not support an OTA antenna. I already have the Roku Ultra and am leaning towards using that with the Tablo DVR rather than the Edge. I’m using Spotify more and am using other services like Disney+. I’ve also pulled all my movies off of the Tivo I have and put them onto a hard drive as MP4 videos and have plugged them into the Roku Ultra I have and can watch all of them just fine. That being said I’ve been with Tivo for a long time bc it’s the best DVR I’ve ever used, so if there is a good argument to use Tivo I’d love to hear it.