I looked at our television watching, and we only had TWO must watch non OTA programs. for that, I'm paying $60 per month. Soooo, I will have a R10 DT Tivo box collecting dust. What is it worth, especially considering there will be no outstanding debt on the box? Definitely staying with Tivo, we love the Tivo! Looking to get S3, especially with the new rebate. Got the antenna already picked out. Figure payback period somewhere around one year. Any reason to even bother with calling retention?