I was a happy TiVo customer in the early S1 days and stayed on for S2. I then jumped ship to DirecTV. I've now been with FiOS since 2006 and I'm tired of paying for HD DVR rentals. It kills me to think I've paid Verizon about $1000 in the last 5 years for DVR rental. I still have an old Toshiba SD-H400 (TiVO with DVD Player) in the closet that I haven't gotten rid of because it has a Lifetime Sub associated with it. It's still functioning but I obviously don't want to use it anymore since it's Pre-HD. I want to replace my two FiOS HD DVRs with two new TiVO Premiers with Lifetime. Does anyone have any prior experience with getting TiVO to do a lifetime transfer on one old box if I offer to pay for one lifetime and purchase two new Premier boxes directly from them?