Seeking Advice & Opinions

Discussion in 'TiVo Premiere DVRs' started by skid71, Mar 21, 2013.

  1. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013

    Advertisements

    Hello all,
    I plan on switching to TiVo/Mini setup when (1) dynamic tuner allocation comes along + new TiVo hardware is available or (2) when our current whole-home system dies (Moxi + Moxi Mates)

    I have a question regarding MoCa.
    Although our current Moxi HDDVR supports MoCA, it cannot act as a bridge/adapter.

    Assuming the "new" TiVo hardware will have the same MoCA capabilities as the current TiVo offerings... Can I remove the Netgear MoCA adapter that currently resides next to the Moxi DVR (which will be replaced by the TiVo DVR)?

    I was hoping to use the adapter at that location in another bedroom for an additional Mini down the road.

    Our current MoCA setup works rather well. We've got three adapters, one at each Moxi/Mate location. I was hoping that the new TiVo would make one of the adapters redundant.

    Is this possible, again assuming that MoCA in the new TiVo is implemented/supported the way it currently is?

    Thanks for opinions, advice, suggestions, etc.

    Skid
     
  2. tatergator1

    tatergator1 Well-Known Member

    2,454
    576
    Mar 27, 2008
    Columbus, Ohio
    The current 4-tuner models can act as MoCA bridges, and the Mini's support MoCA out of the box. Assuming you are able to get Ethernet from your router to the 4-tuner, you wouldn't need any MoCA adapters. The Ethernet would feed the 4-tuner, and then putting the 4-tuner in "Bridge Mode" would then establish a MoCA network that the other Mini's could use around the house via a coax connection between the Mini and your coax outlet at the wall at various TVs.

    Alternatively, if you can not get Ethernet to the 4-tuner, you'd need one MoCA adapter at your router. You'd run Ethernet from your router to the adapter, and then run coax from the adapter to the nearest coax wall outlet, and that would then give you MoCA connectivity to all devices attached to coax throughout the home.

    Finally, assuming the new DVR hardware is equal to the current 4-tuner models for "Bridge Mode," simply replace "4-tuner" with "new DVR" above and it's all the same.
     
  3. jrtroo

    jrtroo Chill- its just TV

    5,095
    322
    Feb 4, 2008
    Chicagoland
  4. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    Interesting. Just to clarify, the Mini also acts as a MoCA bridge? I don't have a diagram, so I'll describe my setup as best I can.

    Basement - Moxi DVR (this location is where the TiVo will go)
    Point of entry coax line connects to Netgear MoCA adapter input
    MoCA adapter output (coax) to Moxi, Ethernet out from MoCA adapter to Moxi ethernet in

    Upstairs - coax into MoCA adapter input, MoCA coax out to Modem in
    Modem ethernet out to wireless router in (ethernet)
    Ethernet out on router to ethernet in on Moxi Mate (TiVo Mini like device)

    Bedroom - coax into MoCA adapter input (no coax output)
    Ethernet out on MoCA adapter to ethernet in on Moxi Mate

    Again, just for clarification...
    I can place the main TiVo in the basement position, connecting only power and coax (removing the MoCA adapter)

    Install Mini in the "Upstairs" location, keeping the MoCA adapter in place, connecting power and ethernet from the router

    Bedroom location install Mini with only power and coax connections.

    Does this sound right?
    Possible network overload in my head.

    Thanks again for the time and help.

    ps... I've read about installing a POE filter. In my setup, where exactly would I install that filter?

    Thanks again for helping out a future TiVo user.

    Skid
     
  5. lpwcomp

    lpwcomp Well-Known Member

    9,461
    298
    May 6, 2002
    John's...

    Advertisements

    That connection makes no sense whatsoever. What kind of internet service do you have?

    Regardless, from this review of the TiVo Mini:

    "Unlike the TiVo Premiere with MoCA, the Mini will not function as a MoCA-to-Ethernet bridge."
     
  6. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    Comcast cable and Internet.
    I'm sure I got something backwards in that setup description.
    I think I'll just swap out the Moxi for the TiVo and the mates for the minis. Remove the MoCA adapter that connects to the MOXI and put the TiVo in bridge mode.

    Appreciate the time and help.

    Skid


    Who cares what this was sent by and how it was sent?
     
  7. lpwcomp

    lpwcomp Well-Known Member

    9,461
    298
    May 6, 2002
    John's...
    Is your current setup working OK?
     
  8. mattack

    mattack Well-Known Member

    25,292
    629
    Apr 9, 2001
    sunnyvale
    No, this was indirectly answered above, and I think is clarified at Tivo's page.
     
  9. Mike-Wolf

    Mike-Wolf New Member

    158
    0
    Feb 25, 2013
    I use both a Moxi and TiVo. Both have their good and bad traits. From what I was told, the 2 tuner TiVo doesn't have the MoCA capabilities that the 4 tuner models have out of the box, which is why it requires two adapters. From reading the website, if you are going for a 4 tuner model I think it's all included and you wouldn't need any adapters at all, however you may need to use a filter which you already mentioned. According to TiVo's website you would need to put the filter on the cable line coming into the house so either at the ground block outside or before the first splitter inside. http://www.tivo.com/mytivo/howto/moca.html#securemoca http://www.tivo.com/assets/pdfs/mytivo/POEFilterInstallation.pdf

    Oh yeah and welcome to the TiVo Family!
     
  10. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    Many thanks to all for taking the time out to help and for the welcome.

    It is sincerely appreciated.
    Enjoy your Friday hoops!

    Regards,
    Skid
     
  11. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    With the exception of a dying hard drive in the Moxi, the setup is working quite nicely. I moved the modem and wireless router from the basement to upstairs. This move has given us better overall wireless performance. And with MoCA adapters over the house we have the ability to extend wireless coverage or install switches for wired hookups.

    When inquiring about the POE filter, I was just a little concerned that our network may be vulnerable.

    Thanks again,
    Skid
     
  12. lpwcomp

    lpwcomp Well-Known Member

    9,461
    298
    May 6, 2002
    John's...
    If all of the boxes can get to the Internet and see each other, I don't see any need for the TiVo to act as a bridge. You don't have a wired Ethernet that you need to bridge to the MOCA. You could split the cable before it goes to the modem and connect the Mini there via Coax. The only thing you might want to add is connect the Ethernet out of that adapter to one of the switch ports of the router.

    There is that, plus I think that the POE filter improves the MOCA signal since it reflects it back. I'm pretty sure it goes at the initial POE of the cable, before any distribution splitters to the various outlets.

    Finally, I hope that someone who knows MOCA better than I do (wouldn't be hard :)) will cut in here if I have made some egregious error . I have never actually used MOCA and am basing my advice on what I have found on the net (no, not just the TCF).
     
  13. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    snip...
    This intrigues me as there are times when it seems our network grinds to the flow of cold molasses. I think I remember seeing the POE filter on TiVo's website. I think a purchase may be in order and try it out.

    The coax outlet that the cable originally came into the house was downstairs and easy to get to. I don't even think there is a splitter in the loop. I'm thinking the coax goes straight into the MoCA adapter downstairs, so I'll just install the filter before it connects to the MoCA adapter.

    Thanks again, and enjoy your weekend!

    Skid
     
  14. lpwcomp

    lpwcomp Well-Known Member

    9,461
    298
    May 6, 2002
    John's...
    There has to be a splitter somewhere. How else would the other outlets be fed?
     
  15. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    I suppose it would have to be in the box outside of the house. I really feel stupid right now. Would it be obvious where to place the POE filter in the box?

    New house...Comcast installed a box on the south side of the house. That has to be where it's split. Wish I could have watched over the build to see how it is wired. The house had coax outlets in each room.

    Skid
     
  16. GBL

    GBL covert opiniative

    2,064
    131
    Apr 20, 2000
    Twin Cities, MN
    Here's a diagram of how a house can be wired for coax:

    [​IMG]

    Note, that if you have more than 1 outlet, the incoming coax line MUST be split. For you, since you have an outlet in each room, it's a matter of finding out where the splitter(s) are (the connection center in the diagram).
     
  17. skid71

    skid71 Member

    215
    24
    Mar 20, 2013
    Oh yeah, certainly more than 1 outlet in the house. Damn, I have no idea where the split could be other than the junction box outside of the garage.
    I'm seriously going nuts at this point. I've been at the house anytime a Comcast "tech" has come out, and I know they haven't ever opened up a wall to get at the wiring. I'm confounded.

    Great diagram BTW.

    Thank you for the continuing help

    Skid
     
  18. tatergator1

    tatergator1 Well-Known Member

    2,454
    576
    Mar 27, 2008
    Columbus, Ohio
    The outside Comcast box is likely just a single cable coming to your home and a single line going into the garage. The split happens somewhere inside. What's on the inside of the garage? I would try to follow the outside Comcast box "through" the wall into the garage and try to find where the line heads next. Do you have a basement?

    Regardless, if you could get access to the Comcast box, that should be a fine place for the POE Filter. The concerns would be "can you get inside the box?" and that Comcast probably doesn't want you messing around in their box.
     
  19. lpwcomp

    lpwcomp Well-Known Member

    9,461
    298
    May 6, 2002
    John's...
    Back when I had a house, the split was right where the cable from the pole go to the house. Most of the wiring to the various outlets ran on the outside wall of the house.

    If I were you, I would call Comcast. Since you have internet with them, they might be willing to install the POE filter for you at no charge. Who knows, there might already be one in place.
     
  20. waynomo

    waynomo My One Time

    15,499
    1,015
    Nov 9, 2002
    Seven...
    FWIW at my house the cable is split outside several times right before it enters the house. Then inside in the basement it is split again a couple of times. Fortunately the splitters inside the house were in the ceiling of the unfinished basement.

    Also, the cable was not installed by the cable company, but by whoever the home builder contracted with. If this is newer construction you might be able to talk to the build and ask them who did it or your neighbors.

    (Or did you say it was Comcast who did the install?)

    _____

    Read above again. So in the scenario I presented, our cable company came out and hooked up to the already existing wire that the builder installed.
     

Share This Page

spam firewall

Advertisements