Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'TiVo Coffee House - TiVo Discussion' started by hoyty, Sep 27, 2008.
Original Post from 9/27/2008 back up at my blog.
Looks like a newer version of the Moxi interface.
I saw this and just thought "so what".
Most people use tivo for one reason.
It records the shows that they like. I don't think the gui really has that much to do with this basic functionality.
If you have chosen Tivo, you have chosen to live with the Tivo Gui.
If you choose your Cable/Satellite provider, then you have chosen whatever GUI they have on their equipment.
Would anybody really care about which Gui they have on their Tivo?
I'm thinking and "hoping" that if Tivo does offer this, that they at least allow us to turn off these extra features.
Case in point.
My Mom who is in her late 40's, my Grandma, and my little brother can walk up to a Tivo and start using it. The remote and screen layout is amazingly simple and easy to use.
Start adding extra pictures and options that aren't needed are only going to confuse users.
I hope that they never release this monstrosity without at least offering me the ability to switch back to the "classic" tivo look.
Tivo GUI could use an update.
Nice looking interface IMO. Taking advantage of the widescreen tv it looks like they found a way to offer all the same menu options, plus some art, and still make it look less cluttered - though there aren't any yellow star ads in your picture
But I vote no. Adding a bunch of stills and cover images makes it more colorful, but not more useful, IMHO.
I do think they managed to retain some TiVo-ness in the look, despite the radical differences.
If this is the new interface it looks great. The only thing thats missing is the TiVo guy. I hope that this will be out sooner then later.
This has to be a hardware upgrade too, right? You can't just do a software upgrade on a TiVoHD and have menu's move that quickly, along with PIP.
The other cool thing about the video is that it shows who you can rent movies and shows from. The list includes, Amazonunbox, Netflix, Blockbuster, and more. It included pricing and had the best priced selected movie on top of the list. Which means that those companies have strong competition which will hopefully drop prices on movies and relax the 24 hour timer for movie rentals.
Looks like TiVo has been doing their homework, their UI has been getting cluttered lately. Can't wait to find out when(if) it will go on sale.
That is not PIP, that is PIG [picture in guide where the one playing picture is squeezed into the corner, and the overlay graphics applied over it, as opposed to one playing video playing scaled in the corner, over another video stream] (I hate it when people get that confused). In any case, it requires the video decoder chip support the necessary scaling, or it be done in software (which current TiVos are incapable of).
This looks fantastic. Please TiVo let this be your new GUI!!!
I really really really really like it. It takes advantage of widescreen HDTV's very well, the picture in guide is a huge missing feature from the current GUI IMO. It also looks like it's more cohesive with all the misc stuff TiVo has tacked on over the years. Additionally, it looks less like it's a crappy SD interface and more like a proper HD one. Hopefully it's at least as responsive if they really deploy it though.
I'm no holding my breath on this one however.
Yeah, I don't know if the PiP (or PiG) could work on current TiVos. The rest is doable on S3/HD, though. (You could do it right now via HME.)
I finally looked at the videos, and I like it better now. I'm still not sure, though.
I switched from 12 YEARS of DirecTV service to Comcast, because DTV had (at the time) ceased dealing with TiVo, and forced me to their heinous in-house interface.
It wasn't the functionality. It wasn't even the uber-cool S3 features I've come to love. It was the ease of use of the GUI, period.
If it didn't look like TiVo, it wouldn't *be* TiVo.
Absolutely hate it. It looks like a bunch of spam everywhere on the screen and just more opportunity to throw ads and other unwanted crap it in your face and slow the system down even more and make for huge downloads of data aside from basic listings. No thanks.
How could you not like the potential new UI? Look at the video's, there is NO load delays from menu to menu. If this thing is real and comes out soon I would be one of the first to get it. This UI upgrade must have been in developement now for years, and looks to be in response to the competition from Windows Media Player, Moxi, and all the other DVR's with sleak interfaces.
Only if we knew when or if this would ever be released.
I'm probably in the minority but UI doesn't concern me anywhere as much as real functional improvements such as (just to name a few):
* co-operative scheduling (ability to manage scheduling and conflict management automatically using your whole set of Tivos)
* ability to load from and save to a computer your season pass & wishlists setups
* ability to delete shows on any Tivo from another Tivo (really part of the co-operative scheduling ability)
* better navigation controls (jump arbitrary n-minutes forwards/back or to any specific time)
* official support for video streaming (beyond simply YouTube but for any video located anywhere) and a much wider array of video formats
Look at the videos on amazon for the current TiVoHD - no delays there - no please wait's (and no ads). Wonders can be done with good video editing.
The thing that amazed me was that they showed viewer tagging for shows in the new GUI.
If it not broke no need to fix. The present guide works great. They are no need to fix or replace it.
It looks like there are certain features that would be good... but if I had the choice of all or nothing, I'd keep the current GUI.
I haven't watched the videos, but I love that there are direct links to movies and downloads on the "TiVo Central" screenshot in the OP. That's pretty much all I think they really need to change.