I currently have two Tivos (S1 and S2) both on Lifetime Subscription The S1 is eligible for transfer for $199. I purchased a TivoHD that I can transfer the lifetime from the S1 to. Would it make more sense? 1. eBay off the S1 and get $199 or higher (depending on how the market price) and use the money to pay for month fees on the Tivo (MSD6.99) 199/7=33months 2. Or transfer the lifetime from the S1 to the TivoHD and pay $199. 33 months for $199/7 and sell the S1 for next to nothing on eBay. What do you guys think? How much would the lifetime S1 fetch now? Hows my logic on this?