The question in the title of this thread may sound strange, but I just got off the phone with Tivo customer service and her answer was no. Can anyone confirm this? Background: I have a S1 Tivo that I bought used in 2002 and have had it on a monthly plan ($12.95/month) ever since. It has started to act a little funny so I purchased a used S2 Tivo. I activated the S2 just under 30 days ago with a monthly multi-service price. I asked the Customer Service rep. if the S1 dies what happens to the monthly price of my S2 when I cancel the S1. Her response was that they have no way to increase my monthly price on the S2, and I would continue to pay the 10.95/month. My concern is that this just does not sound correct. If the price of the S2 is going to increase to 16.95/month for a monthly 1-yr contract, then I want to cancel the current subscription on the S2 and transfer its service number to the S1. If others have had experienced with keeping their multi-service discount without having multiple services then I will not worry about it and let the S1 limp along (90% of the time it works fine). Anyones experience would be appreciated.