I understand why this decision was made but I think it is a mistake. I like this forum and I enjoy comming but I also will upgrade to the latest Direct TV equipment. I think you are doing a disservice to us and your advertisers by not allowing discussion of the new Direct TV PVR on this forum. You will lose many people when the new equipment arrives. Why not just allow discussion of the new PVR in this forum? Just because it is a TIVO community forum does not been it should not evolve. Is there still a Betamax forum? Technologies change and this place should grow with them.