I have a Tivo THD that just went dead... So I dragged the standard Comcast box from upstairs down to the family room until I decide what to do... get a new Premiere or ??? I've always loved the Tivo interface, screen info and channel filtering compared to Comcast. But, Comcast has the OnDemand... Like tonight, after moving the Comcast box, we were able to "catchup" on the shows that are sitting recorded on our dead THD. SO - the coin toss Tivo - has the better interface, more info, channel filtering. Comcast - has bad interface, less info, no channel filtering, BUT has OnDemand. Is having OnDemand worth putting up with the rest of the crappy Comcast screens ?