To make a long story short... I called Tivo up today to activate a third tivo and get the multi service discount. Well, it looks like I'm not eligible for MSD, even though I currently have 2 active tivos going. I then asked the person I was talking to about my 1 year of free service that is about to expire. (in 2 days) She said that I will be put on monthly service for $16.95 a month! No MSD. She talked to people above her and they pretty much said that I am not able to get MSD because "having a lifetime does not count as a plan." I know many of you transferred lifetime service and the 1 year of free service is coming to an end soon. I would like to know what your status of if you pay MSD or full monthly price. Thanks in advance.