Thanks for your reply. I'm not sure where you're getting the 12.85/mo figure.
My gift sub shows it being charged 12.95/mo, being activated Jan 5 , 06 and expiring Nov 06??

Shouldn't that be Jan 07??
It looks like if I go with a S2DT w/3 yr package - total $399, would be ~$11/mo. So, if sticking with my current one would mean 12.85/mo (although the package deals I'm seeing state 16.95/mo as the lowest number) then upgrading seems like it would be the way to go.
If I do that, then what do I do with my current S2ST Tivo? Since its not Lifetimed, I doubt it has much value to anyone else does it?