Thanks for the reply gastrof. I think the reason OTA and Satellite coexist is because they are on different inputs but since I never had local channels via Sat maybe you are right.
I know this. I have to get this resolved. Perhaps you're right maybe TiVO ends up only accessing OTA channels.
I'm curious if there is a different options that I'll try tomorrow. I'm hoping to split the cable feed and provide it to both TiVo and the STB. From what I read, I'll only get the analog FIOS channels but that's more than over the air. The deal breaker is whether TiVO will recognize the channels and the guide will still work.
It's not optimal but it will untether my TiVO and STB. Short of this working I'll have to consider giving up TV or getting a used TiVO