Originally Posted by ZeoTiVo
... the only value left is to move more people off of S1 lifetimes, which doers not seem to be enough in itself yet.
Agree. If Tivo wanted to move people off the S1 lifetimes, the best time to offer the transfer was when the Tivo HD was introduced. The longer the delay, the more S1 lifetime owners will have bought the Tivo HD and put it on the MSD plan. Under MSD, they will want to keep the S1 active as long as possible.