dbeatydbeaty
08-17-2008, 09:28 AM
Thanks to everyone on this forum who has taken the time to report and explain the facts. The FAQ is especially useful. I am a long time ReplayTV user. I have always loved my Sonic Blue but I want digital HD for my Plasma. So I swtiched to Comcast's HD DVR.
The switch has been a real let down, to say the least. So I've decided to remove the Comcast SI box and get a Tivo HD. I purchased one through the refurb program. I'll let you know how that goes. (fingers crossed). I also purchased a WD HD for an internal upgrade.
The features that ReplayTV has that I've come to miss are many when you compare the Comcast box. I wonder if Tivo has all of the Replays capability.
Search guide by text entry field, keywords, with title, director and so on. It searches out through the guide for the entire data base. Returning all programs with those keywords. If I find a program I want, then I can "Find all Shows" of this program in the database to help find the espisode. Does Tivo have this?
SI Comcast has none of this. Only the ability to manually scroll through the guide page by page looking for programs. You can sort the guide, but that's it.
The biggest thing I miss is Replay's ability to remember your place. If you stop a program while viewing. Then return minutes later, days or even weeks and it picks up right where you left off. It remembers this info for any recorded program in the list. Does Tivo have this?
SI Comcast has a timebar with no time markings. If you watch 70 minutes of a 2 hour show, then switch out to another recording, good luck FFing through the entire program to find where you left off. This is so annoying once you have it the other way.
Well Replay has the commercial advance. Nuff said on that.
I read here about codes you can use to modify Tivo. Where do I find a list for the Series 3 DVR's?
Again thanks for those that took the time to report.
DB
The switch has been a real let down, to say the least. So I've decided to remove the Comcast SI box and get a Tivo HD. I purchased one through the refurb program. I'll let you know how that goes. (fingers crossed). I also purchased a WD HD for an internal upgrade.
The features that ReplayTV has that I've come to miss are many when you compare the Comcast box. I wonder if Tivo has all of the Replays capability.
Search guide by text entry field, keywords, with title, director and so on. It searches out through the guide for the entire data base. Returning all programs with those keywords. If I find a program I want, then I can "Find all Shows" of this program in the database to help find the espisode. Does Tivo have this?
SI Comcast has none of this. Only the ability to manually scroll through the guide page by page looking for programs. You can sort the guide, but that's it.
The biggest thing I miss is Replay's ability to remember your place. If you stop a program while viewing. Then return minutes later, days or even weeks and it picks up right where you left off. It remembers this info for any recorded program in the list. Does Tivo have this?
SI Comcast has a timebar with no time markings. If you watch 70 minutes of a 2 hour show, then switch out to another recording, good luck FFing through the entire program to find where you left off. This is so annoying once you have it the other way.
Well Replay has the commercial advance. Nuff said on that.
I read here about codes you can use to modify Tivo. Where do I find a list for the Series 3 DVR's?
Again thanks for those that took the time to report.
DB