Well its only opinion in the sense that ultimately you can do whatever you want and think whatever you want and anything posted should always be considered opinion. No one has had their credentials checked and we're all strangers for the most part so ...its just a guy at the bar going off about something. But any reasonable person would reach the same conclusion as I have because I'm not even close to splitting hairs here. Plus I'm a WMC user. I have no skin in the Tivo game. I never said WMC wasn't good for anyone. People that want computer-related hobbies are good candidates for WMC. But lets not pretend this is but a fraction of a percent of people out there that want a DVR.