I think you and many others are missing the entire point of the thread. I'm NOT talking about just the WMC experience that I and so many people have been using for years with a pc and extenders. Sure, that's the first, interim stage of this, but what I AM talking about is whether the XBox One will REPLACE the current PC portion of that setup (using an external Ethernet or USB cable card tuner and external hard drive (geez how many times do I have to say that in is thread?!?!?!), a la' the Ceton, Silicon Dust, ATI, etc), which we already know from a GUI standpoint is a much different experience for the guide, etc. than the current Windows Media Center. Then you can use the XBox 360s as extenders and media hubs at each of your other TVs which is where you get your LIVE TV, PAUSED TV, TIME SHIFTED RECORDED TV, apps such as TWC, espn, Netflix, Hulu, amazon, etc etc etc.(similar to a roku and many more than TiVo currently or may ever have!) Then of course there's the whole IPTV possibilities. I could go on and on. I KNOW you can't time shift or skip commercials within those apps, but you're also missing the point there as well. Those apps are an ADDED BONUS to the DVR functionality you're already getting with the tuner, e-HDD, XBone, 360 setup I just mentioned above! Imagine you have an HDHR Prime 3CC which only has 3 tuners, and 2 are recording and someone else is watching the third, well NOW you can and have the option of watching another channel of live TV with the TWC or espn apps, without another physical tuner! What I see is TiVo "promising" a lot, which does sound cool, but right now Microsoft already has it, and is a LOT bigger company which bodes well for research and implementation of future technologies and capabilities. Are you seeing the problem NOW? Is anyone even really reading this whole thread? I guess a few hundred years ago you would've told me the world is flat if I would've mentioned I believe there's strong evidence that its round. So, you either want to try to understand what I'm trying to get across here, or not. Want to move into the future, or not.