1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Roamio plus with FIOS and MoCA?

Discussion in 'TiVo Roamio DVRs' started by dswartz, Feb 17, 2014.

  1. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    I'm a tad confused here. Just replaced a series3 (ethernet) with a roamio plus. I have three old nim-100 MoCA bridges elsewhere in the house to get ethernet there - one in the kitchen, one in my stepson's bedroom and one connected to my (non-verizon) router. Everything worked fine, until I tried switching the roamio to MoCA, but it times out and says it can't connect. If I look at MoCA network status, it says 'link down'. Looking at where the verizon guy wired up the coax, I have a 4-way and 2-way splitter. The ONT goes to IN on 2-way. One of the outputs of that goes somewhere (it's hard to tell where). The other goes to IN on the 4-way, and the 4 outputs go wherever they go. The splitters are both rated to 1000mhz, which I've read is okay. I am puzzled as to why that one coax going to the roamio doesn't seem MoCA friendly. I don't see anything in the splitter setup that would just bork the tivo's coax, MoCA-wise. Right around the corner from the roamio is another coax going to the Nim100 connected to the router (well, technically a switch, but...) I had gotten the impression I should just be able to have the roamio join the existing MoCA network, but doesn't seem to be the case. I'm going to try connecting the router's nim100 to the roamio's coax to see if that exonerates that coax run. Any thoughts/ideas would be much appreciated...
     
  2. BigJimOutlaw

    BigJimOutlaw Well-Known Member

    2,858
    57
    Mar 21, 2004
    There have been some reports that the built-in moca support on Tivo devices (moca 1.1) doesn't play nicely with older moca 1.0 networks (such as NIM100's).

    The only options, such as they are, are to use ethernet, use an additional 1.0 adapter for the Tivo's moca connection instead of the integrated moca, or update the moca network to 1.1.
     
  3. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    Hmm, I hadn't heard that (about the 1.0 vs 1.1). I've not had a chance to try swapping the coax cables yet. I'll post my results. Thanks!
     
  4. cmshep222

    cmshep222 Member

    169
    0
    Feb 18, 2005
    I have Fios...you can just plug in the Coax and hook into Moca. I'm a network novice at best, but I got mine (and another house) up an running on Fios Moca.

    Make sure you reboot the Tivo...with NO Ethernet plugged in...just Coax. Then run through the Moca network setup. Tivo should hook into the Fios Moca no prob.
     
  5. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    I tried that. No difference. I'm guessing you don't have nim100 or other moca 1.0 only devices? I think I'll have to shell out for a couple of the $50 moca 1.1 bridges from tivo.com...
     
  6. dianebrat

    dianebrat drastically off narrative TCF Club

    10,417
    164
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    My Roamio didn't like automatically setting the channel in MoCA, I manually set it (to 16 maybe?) and it worked right away. The FiOS router and Roamio will play nice together, I'd test without the other MoCA devices on at first then add them back in.
     
  7. socrplyr

    socrplyr Active Member

    1,092
    8
    Jul 19, 2006
    Just as a double check, how many total devices are you trying to put on the MoCA network. MoCA 1.0 only supports up to 8 devices. Make sure you count the router (if using the FiOS one), any Verizon STB/DVRs, and all of the NIM100s.

    Also, note that if you do buy some from Tivo, you can save $10 by buying the 2 pack if you need multiple.
     
  8. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    I don't have the verizon router - I use my own. There are a total of 3 NIM-100 units in the house, so the TiVo would make 4. dianebrat, thanks for the suggestion. I had tried a channel manually, but I don't remember which one. Do you have MoCA 1.0 units at all? I keep hearing that the roamio doesn't like them. My problem is: if this is the issue, I will have to replace all 3 NIM-100 units, which is a little pricy. I might buy just one to see if the roamio sees it. If it does (but not the others), I could spring for 2 more in the 2-pack. I will try various channels tonight and see how that works...
     
  9. sangs

    sangs Member

    533
    2
    Jan 1, 2003
    New Jersey
    You know the other option is getting a FiOS router - either from Verizon or on EBay - and just setting it up so that it passes MoCA along the wire. Might be easier and cheaper.
     
  10. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    I'm not sure what you're getting at. The whole point of this exercise is so I don't have to run a cat5 to the roamio. I can do so (and in fact am), it's just inconvenient. As it is now, the two rooms are on the LAN via coax (nim-100) and the 3rd nim-100 links the coax segments to the LAN. How would a verizon router help me in this scenario? Unless you mean to stick it next to the roamio to provide ethernet? If I was going to do that, I may as well get another nim-100 on ebay or something. Or maybe get one of the actiontec moca units to do this (assuming they play well with 1.0 units like nim-100).
     
  11. BigJimOutlaw

    BigJimOutlaw Well-Known Member

    2,858
    57
    Mar 21, 2004
    NIMs were pretty popular and cheap for a time so it does suck having to consider replacing them. You could alternatively find another NIM100 and connect it to the back of the Roamio rather than replace the entire network. This can be tested by temporarily moving a NIM to the Roamio and see if it connects.

    Perhaps try replacing just the primary NIM at the router with an actiontec adapter? Maybe the Tivo will like it better and the NIMs will still work. Shot in the dark.

    edit: posted before refreshing to see new post :)
     
  12. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    For the moment, it's working with a spare powerline adapter. If I was going to buy exactly one actiontec adapter, I'd be inclined to hang it off the roamio and call it a day. What I may do (to spread out the $$$ pain) is buy one actiontec unit and put it in place of the nim-100 by the router. If the roamio can link with it okay (might need to unplug the other nim-100s to avoid interference?), put it behind the roamio and put the nim-100 back in place, with some confidence that I can later spring for two more AT units and replace the nim100's altogether...
     
  13. sangs

    sangs Member

    533
    2
    Jan 1, 2003
    New Jersey
    Sorry, maybe I'm just confused. I wasn't suggesting using the FiOS router for Ethernet, but for MoCA. If you have the FiOS router in the equation, it automatically sends MoCA over the existing coax. You don't need Cat 5, Cat 6, Ethernet cable or any MoCA adapters at all, just the coax. (You can still use a MoCA to Ethernet adapter anywhere along the coax runs too.)
     
  14. HarperVision

    HarperVision TiVo's Italian Cuz!

    5,275
    9
    May 14, 2007
    Paradise...
    Another, cheaper option you can try if you don't need any raw rf cable signals throughout your house is to get a couple DirecTV DECA units from ebay, etc and use those as "moca" devices through your home's coax. They are the same as a moca device, but just use a different frequency band to transmit it's signals. They did that because normal moca frequencies are in the same freq range as their IF satellite signals, which means that they are now in the freq band of normal cable signals, so you can't have or use any raw rf cable signals on the same line. If all you have are minis in your other rooms, you can home run your cable signal to the Roamio location and connect it to your main Roamio, then split the rest of your house off and connect the minis and any other ethernet devices (using a switch) with the deca units.

    I did this since I already had the existing DirecTV SWiM infrastructure installed for their Genie system. Works quite well actually, even easier than when I initially tried moca using my pro. Nothing I seemed to do worked in that scenario.

    Just a thought..........
     
  15. mae

    mae member

    250
    5
    Dec 10, 2001
    USA
    I just replaced my dead Premier XL, connected via a NIM 100 with a Roamio Plus. I do have FIOS, with a Rev I Actiontec, and could not get it to connect to the MOCA network, although it worked fine with the NIM. Even with the NIM unplugged from power and network, the Roamio would not connect. The Actiontec LAN Coax stats showed the MOCA version as .1 and a VZ set top box as the network controller. I finally took all the MOCA devices off line, rebooted everything and brought them back on line, starting with the router and then the Roamio. It connected right away and the LAN coax stats on the Actiontec now shows version 1.1 and the Roamio as the controller.

    In summary, I think I confirmed what others are saying that the Roamio does not play well with NIM 100's. In my case even removing the NIM didn't resolve the legacy issue until everything reset.

    I'd go with used Actiontecs off Ebay to use as bridges to replace the NIMs, but if you want to stay with them and add another to your network in place of the Roamio's built in, I'll be putting mine on ebay :). (update - just looked...there's one with a current high bid of 99 cents - probably just throw it in the box 'o stuff or give it away)
     
  16. cmshep222

    cmshep222 Member

    169
    0
    Feb 18, 2005

    Agree with Sangs. My suggestion above assumed you were using the Fios Actiontec router. That has Moca already available on it. Sorry for the confusion.
     
  17. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    I ordered one of the actiontec moca bridges from tivo.com. I'm going to put it in place of the nim100 next to the router. If gives the roamio network connectivity, I will spring for 2 more and just throw the nim100s on ebay or something...
     
  18. dianebrat

    dianebrat drastically off narrative TCF Club

    10,417
    164
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    You said FiOS in post 1 and didn't specifically call out that you were not using the standard Verizon supplied Actiontec router they leverage to do the MoCA to ethernet in 90% of all installations, can't blame us for assuming it was in the loop.

    Even then the GigE Actiontec is only $79 at Verizon and usually 1/2 that on ebay, I'd lean towards using that as your MoCA ingress since it's so reliable and cheap.
     
  19. dswartz

    dswartz New Member

    36
    0
    Oct 8, 2007
    Dianebrat, I'm not blaming anyone. That said, I'm not wild about a unit that has all the extra things that need to be tweaked or turned off. Note that my current setup has no smart MoCA unit - just 3 bridges (the nim100's). I can get MoCA 1.1 bridges through tivo.com for about $50 each and they are new, and should be drop-in replacements for the nim100's. All of that said, you haven't said if you have nim100's or not. If you do, and they don't talk to the roamio, then the tivo that has LAN access via a nim100 will not be visible to the roamio, so no show transfers, etc, which obviates the whole point of this exercise.
     
  20. sangs

    sangs Member

    533
    2
    Jan 1, 2003
    New Jersey
    Are you referring to the FiOS router? Because I'm not sure what you mean about things needing to be tweaked or turned off. It's a pretty simple setup. Coax or Ethernet from the FiOS ONT to the FiOS Router--Coax to Roamio/Mini--Use MoCA on the Roamio/Minis. That's it. No settings need changing from what I recall and no adapters needed anywhere along the line. Not trying to change your mind, just looking for clarification.
     

Share This Page