1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Mythbusters - Titanic Survival

Discussion in 'Now Playing - TV Show Talk' started by LifeIsABeach, Oct 10, 2012.

  1. LifeIsABeach

    LifeIsABeach New Member

    2,358
    0
    Feb 28, 2001
    Drexel Hill, PA
    Has anyone watched this? Usually I get annoyed by the people who complain they got things wrong, but this episode had me scratching my head.

    All during the build team's experiment I was thinking:

    1. The guy in the picture obviously only had one big rocket
    2. I doubt he was skilled enough to time various rockets
    3. He did not have a specially shaped surfboard or a handhold
    4. Corey's ride was nowhere near 30 seconds

    At least at the end they redeemed themselves and busted the myth. Usually they bust it first and then try to duplicate the results.


    I also did not like what Adam and Jamie did.

    1. Why would you use "authentic" prop wood? The movie is supposed to be recreating the Titanic. You need to use the type of wood which would have been on the Titanic.

    2. By their own hypothermia results they should have concluded that Rose would have been too frozen to blow her whistle by the time the boat came back to rescue them. Therefore they both would have died either way.
     
  2. heySkippy

    heySkippy oldweakandpathetic

    19,968
    38
    Jul 2, 2001
    Sarasota, FL
    I thought it was entertaining enough. It was clear from the first test that the acceleration of a single large rocket was an overwhelming hurdle, so they went straight to trying to make it work on their own.

    As for the Titanic part, Cameron was pretty funny. I didn't much care about the outcome, but watching the builds and tests was interesting.

    Overall, a better than average episode for the last few years.
     
  3. Regina

    Regina I've got Jewbs!

    1,575
    0
    Mar 29, 2003
    Indiana
    I've said for years that they could have just taken turns up above, for crying out loud! :p;)
     
  4. snowjay

    snowjay 40mph couch potato

    15,437
    1
    Mar 26, 2007
    Almost in...

    I think they did. They said at one point they contacted some maritime museum and tried to recreate what was on the ship as closely as possible.
     
  5. Donbadabon

    Donbadabon Geocacher

    3,093
    2
    Mar 5, 2002
    Franklin, TN

    I didn't like the surfboard tests either. Maybe they put a lot of thought/testing into the one-rocket method but they didn't show it to us. So we are left with this crazy multi-rocket board.
     
  6. Hank

    Hank AC•FTW

    20,884
    9
    May 31, 2000
    Boston, MA
    But they were testing the absolute "worst case" scenario that she was rescued at the 63 minute mark, and not before. If that's the case, then yes, I'd agree that it's unlikely she would have been able to blow the whistle. But what about 45 minutes? I would say unless you're the one out there, at 63 minutes, and not dead yet, that it's hard to tell if you'd be able to blow a whistle. If it were me, the whistle would already have been frozen to my mouth, and all I needed to do was blow a little harder.
     
  7. pmyers

    pmyers Active Member

    14,876
    3
    Jan 4, 2001
    Gilbert, AZ
    Does anybody really care about that Titanic myth?
     
  8. LifeIsABeach

    LifeIsABeach New Member

    2,358
    0
    Feb 28, 2001
    Drexel Hill, PA
    I'll have to go back and rewatch. I thought they said they used the same type of wood they used in the film (which had no need to be accurate). Thanks!
     
  9. Hoffer

    Hoffer Captain Chaos

    36,242
    36
    Jun 1, 2001
    Twin Cities, MN
    I didn't care. I fast forwarded past the final bit with the 2 guys trying to be on the piece of wood.

    I did find the hypothermia thing interesting. That the body temperature would drop the same whether you're in the water or not.

    As to blowing the whistle, didn't Rose swim to someone nearby to blow the whistle? They were saying when that cold, you can't move anymore. That is why Jack sunk.
     
  10. pmyers

    pmyers Active Member

    14,876
    3
    Jan 4, 2001
    Gilbert, AZ
    But in the 2 person test, they were still both in the water, just not totally submerged. And I wonder if there was wind, would being out of the water actually be worse (assuming water and air temp the same).
     
  11. doom1701

    doom1701 Time for a new Title

    25,293
    3
    May 15, 2001
    Grand...
    I thought the surfing myth was fun--obviously they went to replicating the results almost immediately. The ride with the dummy, since he was strapped onto the board (and the board was on rails) was more impressive looking.

    I really liked the Titanic myth. I thought Cameron was a blast. The methodology seemed solid as well, although (like many people online), I do debate that anybody in freezing cold water would have the clarity of mind to tie the life jacket around the wood. I do now wonder about Hoffer's point--I can't remember when Rose got the whistle. If she did get off the board before rescue, then she should be dead.

    I think the only thing that bugged me was the 63 minute figure. It really stunk of "We know the timing of hypothermia--so let's pick a time that is just barely under the limit, both medically and historically."
     

Share This Page