This is 'as intended'. mpeg-2 native does no conversion of the file.. IT simply reads it off the network and decrypts it inline. This pretty much is a 'as fast as you can download it'. In order to remove commercials, the file has to be processed and re-encoded. Since mpeg-2 native doesn't re-encode, it can't remove commercials.
If you want an mpeg-2 stream without commercials, select one of the DVD mpeg-2 formats, which do re-encode.
Ok, just a warning though, comskip has been making really BAD mistakes for low-quality shows (I mean bitrate). So I recommend not using it on those or at least checking the results before using... med-quality to HD has been working fine I think.
I have a single tuner s2 with an hard drive upgrade so I record everything in high quality SD and it has worked fine for my tests. I have also tested some med-quality clips with success. It might clip a few frames here and there but nothing too annoying.
This is 'as intended'. mpeg-2 native does no conversion of the file.. IT simply reads it off the network and decrypts it inline. This pretty much is a 'as fast as you can download it'. In order to remove commercials, the file has to be processed and re-encoded. Since mpeg-2 native doesn't re-encode, it can't remove commercials.
If you want an mpeg-2 stream without commercials, select one of the DVD mpeg-2 formats, which do re-encode.
Yoav,
Thanks so much for the updates! Unfortunately, your solution only works for SD content, not HD mpeg2. It would be great to have an option that would download the mpeg2, then strip the commercials and output mpeg2 that is the same resolution as the source.
Yoav,
Thanks so much for the updates! Unfortunately, your solution only works for SD content, not HD mpeg2. It would be great to have an option that would download the mpeg2, then strip the commercials and output mpeg2 that is the same resolution as the source.
Ok shouldn't be too hard to add that. (Although it will have to be forced to a resolution (either 1920x1080 or 1200x720). In the meanwhile you can make edits to:
Updated to reflect release 1.3.2
(an emergency bugfix release)
There was a pretty nasty bug that caused downloads to loop forever if comskip wasn't selected.
Sure...
(if you have any ideas on what the flags should be, download the beta and specify the flags under advanced prefs.. Otherwise, I'll try some things myself here and hopefully figure it out).
I could only test it a bit this morning, but it seems to work well. I got a much smaller file as an mp3 than for the iPhone, and it sounds fine in iTunes.
When imported into iTunes, an hour show is listed as 3:25:35. When listening on the iPhone, it ends at the one hour mark, so no big deal. This is not a problem at all for me.
I'll recap my problem from another thread and add an update here ...
"I've tried four times now to tansfer a movie\tv show and none of the will open in Quick Time, Final Cut Pro, etc. The last two errors were "The movie could not be opened. An invalid sample description was found in the movie".
I have plenty of free drive space. The setting are AppleTV, no comskip, the TV Show shows up as HD in the selection window, but it's off of the Comedy Channel (at best it's digital not HD). I tried iTivo 1.4 and the latest beta. I'm running Leopard 10.5.5.
Any idea what's going wrong? My ultimate goal is to take some of the shows off of my TivoHD (9.4) and move them over to my AppleTV for storage and longterm watching."
Update: If I select "iPhone" in preferences as the download format it encodes successfully, but "AppleTV" as the format is not successful an returns the error noted above. Is there something wrong with the AppleTV settings?
I'll recap my problem from another thread and add an update here ...
"I've tried four times now to tansfer a movie\tv show and none of the will open in Quick Time, Final Cut Pro, etc. The last two errors were "The movie could not be opened. An invalid sample description was found in the movie".
I have plenty of free drive space. The setting are AppleTV, no comskip, the TV Show shows up as HD in the selection window, but it's off of the Comedy Channel (at best it's digital not HD). I tried iTivo 1.4 and the latest beta. I'm running Leopard 10.5.5.
Any idea what's going wrong? My ultimate goal is to take some of the shows off of my TivoHD (9.4) and move them over to my AppleTV for storage and longterm watching."
at it encodes successfully, but "AppleTV" as the format is not successful an returns the error noted above. Is there something wrong with the AppleTV settings?
Multi-part answer (keep in mind I don't have an appletv to test with).
AppleTV setting does a bit-copy of the audio stream. From HD content that's entirely playable in quicktime, but from regular content quicktime doesn't know what to do.
I'll have it re-encode all audio to faac 5.1 irrelevant of the source I suppose.
Soemthing to keep in mind though. for regular TV you probably don't want to use AppleTV as your setting, since that tries to keep data at 1200x720 (which is bigger than your source)
I just updated from 1.2.1 to 1.4.
It will not connect to my TiVo.
I know the IP and MAC are correct because I can cut and paste into https://IP. Also the "Now Playing" widget works.
(It also lets you use List View or Folder View. And there's a neat pie graph to be able to visualize storage space used.)
But it's for Windows only.
I've tried to install it on my Mac using CodeWeavers Crossover with no success. If this capability were to be included with iTiVo, it would be even more fantastic.
I just updated from 1.2.1 to 1.4.
It will not connect to my TiVo.
I know the IP and MAC are correct because I can cut and paste into https://IP. Also the "Now Playing" widget works.
Yoav - Almost actually. Appears AppleTV doesn't like multi-channel audio. What would be the encoder audio options setting for "stereo". Can I just copy the setting from mpeg2 or the like?
From what I understand, the AppleTV can only use AC3 (aka Dolby Digital 5.1) audio when it is the second audio track in the file and the first audio track is a 2 channel AAC.
It might make sense to just force the AppleTV audio to 2 channel AAC.
From what I understand, the AppleTV can only use AC3 (aka Dolby Digital 5.1) audio when it is the second audio track in the file and the first audio track is a 2 channel AAC.
It might make sense to just force the AppleTV audio to 2 channel AAC.
If that's the case, then change -channels 6 to -channels 2 in the advanced audio prefs and tell me if that works. (if it does, I'll fix it in the source).
Yoav - changing it from -6 to -2 channel didn't work. It imports into iTunes but iTunes won't transfer it to AppleTV indicating "it can not be played on this AppleTV".
I'm not seeing what could be the problem. Apple indicates:
H.264 and protected H.264 (from iTunes Store): Up to 5 Mbps, Progressive Main Profile (CAVLC) with AAC-LC audio up to 160 Kbps (maximum resolution: 1280 by 720 pixels at 24 fps, 960 by 540 pixels at 30 fps) in .m4v, .mp4, and .mov file formats
When I check the video properties in iTunes it shows: MPEG-4, bit rate 245 kbps, Stereo, Total bit rate 3250 kbps, 1195x672, Video codes H.264
An early Comedy Central program that I had trouble with transcoded with the original AppleTV setting just fine. I suspect that is because the original sound track was only 2 channel. When inspecting it's properties it states: MPEG-4, 274 kbps, Stereo, 3316 kbps, 960x720, H.264
Any ideas on what changes I need to make?
Thanks.
Mark.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
TiVo Community Forum
9.4M posts
278K members
Since 2001
A forum community dedicated to TiVo digital video recorder owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about programming, streaming, content, schedules, home theaters, displays, models, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!