After talking to TiVo Customer service this morning, I'm really tempted to get the $49 Premiere, transfer my current service to it, and take the $99 Lifetime deal on the TiVoHD. Transferring my current service to the Premiere would keep the TiVo Service fee the same. If I use the Premiere OTA, I'd have two more tuners for the Thursday night logjam, and I wouldn't have to mess with re-pairing the current cable card, or adding any cable card fees. Of course that would depend on whether or not they'd give me the $99 Lifetime deal for a Premiere and not a Roamio. But if I could keep our monthly costs the same, it would help the SAF (spouse acceptance factor). I really appreciate the advice everybody has given about the Roamio, though. Talking about getting a Roamio and upgrading it has suddenly made upgrading the computer a lot more appealing. The $49 Premiere deal wouldn't be as nice as getting a Roamio, but it would get me back to the 4 tuners we had before Comcast went all digital. The alternative would be to get one of the stupid Comcast DTAs and watch (ick phtooie) Live TV on the nights where we have conflicts that call for more than two tuners.