1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Caller ID on television with TiVo Roamio & Premiere / caller ID on TV without cable

Discussion in 'TiVo Roamio DVRs' started by HiFi777, Jan 2, 2014.

  1. Jan 2, 2014 #1 of 53
    HiFi777

    HiFi777 New Member

    3
    0
    Jan 2, 2014
    Many TiVo users want Caller ID on screen, but TiVo took that away with Series 4, ridiculously enough! Even though many people switching from cable set-top boxes / DVRs are now used to caller ID on TV, TiVo obviously won't bring it back, and it looks like there's only one outside device that can do it while keeping video at HD quality.


    Summary:

    Caller ID on screen is a recurring topic on TCF since the ability was lost with Series 4, but there hasn't been a new solution offered on this board in years.

    60% of American households have landline telephone service. Cable TV STB/DVR provide caller ID on-screen for incoming calls, when subscribed to a cable double-play and triple-play bundle with digital telephone service.

    Many consumers find caller ID on TV convenient. People who switch from cable STB / DVR to TiVo -- or who cut the cord entirely -- may still want on-screen caller ID. Roamio and Premiere are not hackable like previous TiVo models to add this feature. I found one solution, a DIY device that keeps television content at HD quality, called the NeTV. It is paired with a USB modem or ATA box (like a Vonage, Obi, or Linksys SPA device) and open-source NCID software to transmit the caller ID information.


    Full version:

    Background

    Longtime lurker here. After becoming a cable 'cord cutter' and buying TiVo, I spent hours of research here and elsewhere trying to figure out how to get caller ID on screen.

    (Before anyone jumps in with the usual sarcastic quips about caller ID on television, please see my preemptive answers in the section below.)

    Most of the threads on TCF addressing this topic -- some of which I've compiled in a list at the bottom -- are more than 2 years old, and have thoroughly hashed out the pros and cons of on-screen caller ID.

    As many of you probably know, Caller ID on the TV screen was possible with TiVo in the past with DirecTiVo and with series 1 or by modding / hacking the EEPROM on series 2 and series 3 models.

    But that ability was lost with TiVo Premiere and Roamio.

    Desire for on-screen Caller ID

    A majority of American households (60.6%) have landline telephone service (source: CDC-NCHS, Dec. 2013), with many households using Vonage, MagicJack, Ooma, CMRS Wireless Home Phone by AT&T / Verizon / Straight Talk / T-Mobile / Sprint, or another VoIP provider.

    Many people with cable TV with set-top box service have become accustomed to caller ID on screen. It's likely that some people cutting the cord from cable triple-play or double-play bundle service or who are switching from their MSO cable provider STB/DVR to TiVo would like to keep their old 'default' option for caller ID information on-screen.

    As other posters have eloquently stated in past threads:

    Fofer:
    ah30k:
    miller890:
    JWThiers:
    BlackBetty:

    Other, old solutions

    I looked at some of the workaround solutions people have discussed previously, but they're ugly.

    1. The CallerTV box, by NetMedia, inserts itself between the TiVo and the television, but uses composite video for it's signal in and signal out (no HDMI model available), which creates an ugly result, obviously. Also, the Roamio doesn't have analog out, so you couldn't use this device (without a digital-to-analog converter or DAC) even if you wanted to.

    2. The TelNote, by Southlake, is just a gawky device (connected only to the telephone line, not the television devices) -- especially to have it sit on or adjacent to your TV in an otherwise sleek entertainment center. (And it's $50-$90+, which is expensive for what it does).


    New solution

    I spent hours looking for a solution that would:

    1) place caller ID information on screen, while
    2) keeping the video signal in high-definition (HDMI)

    I already submitted a feature request through TiVo's website for caller ID on-screen with the Premiere through a TiVo approved add-on device, but obviously that's not actually going to be realized.

    The only solution I could find that's for sale at this time is a DIY (do-it-yourself) device called the NeTV by Adafruit. It's a cousin to the Raspberry Pi, which was covered in the tech news a lot in 2012 and 2013.

    The NeTV is placed between the TiVo and the television -- it has HDMI passthrough, with an HDMI input that comes from your TiVo or other tuner and and an HDMI output that goes to the television.

    You add an analog telephone adapter (ATA) with an RJ-11 jack (to insert the telephone line), so you can capture the caller ID information from incoming calls.

    As your ATA, you can use either a USB modem or a full-scale telephony device (I believe that Vonage and Obi boxes and the Linksys SPA-1302 would work). After researching it, I believe that the ATA can be located in an entirely different room (e.g., where the telephone line comes in), and can transmit the caller ID information from the ATA by ethernet or WiFi (depending on the ATA specs) to the NeTV.

    There is an open-source software effort (called NCID on Sourceforge) to help with capturing caller ID information from the ATA, transmitting it to the NeTV, and displaying it on-screen. TCF user JLC has written about this effort previously.

    For more info, also look at the posts by user TAA on the Kosagi website. Also, TCF user LRHorer has discussed in previous posts how he set up his Vonage ATA to send caller ID information over Ethernet/WiFi to his NCID clients and had the information display on-screen.


    Preemptive answers to the usual sarcastic responses

    TCF user Tiassa usually jumps into these caller ID threads to say:

    My response: See other TCF users' response above. In summary, the whole reason I want caller ID on screen is that I'm already looking at the TV screen, so I want the information on that screen.


    TCF user AbMagFab has responded that he doesn't have a telephone jack near his TiVo and doesn't want to run a telephone line to the television area.

    My response: As I note above, you can keep the ATA device in a separate area near the telephone jack, and it can still transmit caller ID information by WiFi or ethernet to the NeTV.


    TCF user Sugarbowl suggested just using the Telnote to avoid the difficulties of caller ID on screen.

    My response: I'm not interested in a separate gawky device in the field of vision like the Telnote marring on an otherwise 'clean' looking entertainment center.



    Main old threads from TCF about caller ID on-screen with TiVo

    "Caller ID and Screensaver?"
    TCF showthread.php?t=447275

    "Caller ID on-screen"
    TCF showthread.php?t=351434

    "Caller ID?"
    TCF showthread.php?t=495937

    "Wife asks where is Caller ID?"
    TCF showthread.php?t=430359

    "On screen caller id? "
    TCF showthread.php?t=351417
     
  2. Jan 2, 2014 #2 of 53
    lessd

    lessd Active Member

    7,695
    5
    Jan 23, 2005
    CT
    For some Comcast customers TiVo added OD so I guess they could add the Tel number on the screen, but I don't know if that would require some additional hardware on TiVos part.
     
  3. Jan 3, 2014 #3 of 53
    HiFi777

    HiFi777 New Member

    3
    0
    Jan 2, 2014
    As I understand it, on-demand (VOD) programming is a separate set of signalling functions from caller ID.

    In other words, while Comcast was able to figure out how to do two-way communication with a CableCard-enabled TiVo for OD, you're unlikely to see most MSOs offer caller ID on screen to TiVo.

    My guess is that there are technical problems with offering it, or that they are limiting caller ID on screen to their own DVRs to lock people into lucrative monthly rental fees.
     
  4. Jan 3, 2014 #4 of 53
    dianebrat

    dianebrat I refuse to accept your reality TCF Club

    10,118
    75
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    Or that it's just a niche feature that isn't really in demand.. I don't know of a single person in my family and friends that has it or would care about it and 50% of us have no land lines, obviously YMMV.
     
  5. Jan 3, 2014 #5 of 53
    HiFi777

    HiFi777 New Member

    3
    0
    Jan 2, 2014
    ...which is exactly why so many cable companies make it a default setting for all digital subscribers with phone service... :confused:

    ...and clearly you and your friends speak for all American consumers ... In that case, do I get to blame dumb reality TV programming and the folks in PeopleOfWalmart on you then?


    By the way, do you really want to make the implied claim that not a single one of all your friends and family members is a cable subscriber with a set-top box or DVR that displays caller ID on-screen or might want such a thing? :rolleyes:

    Incidentally, I think you may have missed the many TiVo users quoted in the original post discussing their desire for caller ID on screen.

    Or you may have missed the fact that many cable companies offer this feature.

    And you understandably missed how a google search for this feature brings up extensive amounts of information on how to use this feature -- and plenty of webpages with non-cable subscribers asking for something equivalent.



    [​IMG]
     
  6. Jan 3, 2014 #6 of 53
    dianebrat

    dianebrat I refuse to accept your reality TCF Club

    10,118
    75
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    A: Yes I can attest that my friends and family don't give a care about this feature, in fact the subject has come up in discussion in the past and none of my close circle could see a desire for it, they have cell phones, and those are usually at hand.
    B: A handful of us here at TCF are not representative of the global community wanting features or not wanting features
    C: Cable companies offer lots of things some users don't care about.
    D: What some folks care about others do not
    E: I am aware of how to Google..

    As much as you want to post War and Peace on my short comment, the fact is that this isn't a "killer app" feature, and I would wager the majority of DVR users probably don't care about it.

    As important it is for you to have written your extensive initial post, it's equally unimportant to others. There are plenty of features that could be on my list to be added before you'd ever get to Caller ID, I don't even have a land line anymore, I haven't for almost 10 years.

    The fact is land lines are going away at a record pace, it would not be a wise business move to invest time and energy in developing a feature for a market that is decreasing that rapidly, I applaud Tivo for not going there.
     
  7. Jan 3, 2014 #7 of 53
    jay_man2

    jay_man2 jay_man-also

    4,318
    2
    Sep 14, 2003
    Northern...
    I'm with db on this. I don't need another way to see that "UNKNOWN" is calling my landline, which I only have because triple play is cheaper than double play. :p
     
  8. Jan 4, 2014 #8 of 53
    L David Matheny

    L David Matheny Active Member

    1,588
    1
    Jan 29, 2011
    SE Ohio
    TiVo could probably offer on-screen caller ID, but (as with the cable company offerings) it could be done easily only for customers whose phone service is delivered via TV cable, not for those with a normal phone line. The cable companies want to promote that because it encourages people to use them for (Internet) phone service. TiVo has no such ulterior motive.

    To offer on-screen caller ID for people with a real (not Internet) phone line, TiVo would have to add a phone jack and caller ID hardware, neither of which would serve any other purpose. Could they do that? Of course. They could also offer features like an on-screen indoor/outdoor thermometer, but why should they complicate their hardware and firmware for things so far removed from DVR functionality?
     
  9. Jan 4, 2014 #9 of 53
    lessd

    lessd Active Member

    7,695
    5
    Jan 23, 2005
    CT
    A smart TV could do the same thing if wanted but a phone line is not normally available at TiVo or TV places, to run a phone line would be a pain to many people, the cable system uses the CID from the cable itself that everybody with a cable provider has to have at the TiVo and or a cable box. I have only seen it used once and everybody has it that uses a Comcast cable box. Comcast can also download a program that gives you CID on your internet connected computer, I tried it, was a pain because I have two Comcast lines.
     
  10. sfrazier9999

    sfrazier9999 New Member

    4
    0
    Oct 27, 2003
    I did a request to tivo for callerid on the roamio and was told to switch go it. That was 6 mos ago.

    I guess they aren't going to do it unless anyone knows.
     
  11. sfrazier9999

    sfrazier9999 New Member

    4
    0
    Oct 27, 2003
    I will buy if they add it a new roamio and minis. I have the xl but won't spend any more money with them unless they do. Shouldn't be that difficult.
     
  12. dianebrat

    dianebrat I refuse to accept your reality TCF Club

    10,118
    75
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    I have no idea what you're trying to say in your first post, you may want to reread it.

    Sorry to see you go, but there really isn't much possibility that this is ever going to be on the Tivo feature list, as I stated above, it's a shrinking market considering how fast people are leaving land lines.
     
  13. davezatz

    davezatz Funkadelic

    4,587
    3
    Apr 18, 2002
    Northern...
    TiVo and RCN just announced Caller ID on Premiere, Mini, and Roamio. It requires rental TiVo gear from RCN, of course, along with digital voice service, of course.

    http://www.rcn.com/about-rcn/newsroom/rcn-offers-callerid-on-tivo

    But, yeah, doubt they'd waste resources on opening this up to landlines via retail boxes.
     
  14. eboydog

    eboydog Just TiVo'ing.....

    904
    0
    Mar 23, 2006
    With more and more households getting rid of land lines, callerid on screen is a thing of the past. The only reason the MSO boxes support it is due to the fact the provider offers a land line type telephone service and they are creating a feature for a service that isn't necessary. The only time it was slightly useful was when there was a requirment for TiVo to be connected to the phone lines for its nightly call in, considering who telemarketers and mobile numbers can spoof any identification by callerid, there is no longer a need for such.

    OP mentioned 60 percent of households have landlines, I really question that and would be interested were they come up with that, of the people I know and contacts, all are switching to cell based lines including those over 50 year old crowd. It's simply nuts to be paying $50 for a landline service that duplicates the services your cell phone has, I tried even cutting back to IP based home line such as Vonage and found there was no need for it.

    TiVo removed the "feature" because in 2013, it wasn't used or needed by the majority and today would require another wire hooked up that only purpose is provide callerid on screen.
     
  15. dianebrat

    dianebrat I refuse to accept your reality TCF Club

    10,118
    75
    Jul 6, 2002
    boston'ish
    Even if accurate, that's 60% and DROPPING, there's no business I know of that would invest in a product that has a decreasing user base.
     
  16. squint

    squint New Member

    846
    0
    Jun 15, 2008
    I think series 3 Tivos have had this user-added feature for years now.
     
  17. tarheelblue32

    tarheelblue32 Active Member

    3,645
    5
    Jan 12, 2014
    Raleigh, NC
    I guess it would be a nice little feature to have, but there are much more important features TiVo needs to focus on adding. Trying to add caller ID would be a distraction of time and resources. Maybe once TiVo has added all the other features they need to, they can come back to Caller ID, but at the rate TiVo moves, that could take decades.
     
  18. djl25

    djl25 C64 hacker

    95
    0
    May 26, 2005
    Providence, RI
    Just for the sake of argument, this doesn't have to be limited to landlines. There are several Bluetooth gateways that will ring your house phone when a cell call comes in. Such calls could easily be shown on screen, giving you the chance to decide whether to get up and hunt for your cell phone! Also, for some of us it just gets our geek going...
    Full disclosure, I contribute to the ncid TiVo branch, so I'm all in favor of this anyway.
     
  19. DeltaOne

    DeltaOne Mount Airy, MD

    269
    0
    Sep 29, 2013
    I'm over 50 and I've kept my landline for one reason -- reliable 911 service.

    I did, however, switch to metered service for the landline. Incoming calls are free, outgoing calls are ten cents each and there's no long distance plan. We use our smart phones for everything, but I want the 100% reliability of traditional 911 service.

    When I switched the landline to metered service it was $15 a month. Seems worth it to me. Price jumps now have it at $20 a month. There are three of us in the house now -- everyone knows to use their smartphone when they make an outgoing call (local and long distance).
     
  20. lessd

    lessd Active Member

    7,695
    5
    Jan 23, 2005
    CT
    I pay $21/month to Comcast for a full feature land line, all outgoing calls inc LD are free.
     

Share This Page