I wasn't really sure where to post this. But I figure this is less about what DVR I'd replace it with as much as it is about the fact that I'm really hesitant about giving up my Premiere. As unhappy as I am with Comcast as a company and considering the money it would save me, it's the only reason I haven't switched to DTV or DISH. I've done a fair amount of searching Google and digging through forums, with only a small amount of success. It's hard to find direct comparisons between the Premiere and the HR34, THR22, Hopper, etc., I'm assuming because the Tivo fills a separate niche and is not generally the deciding factor. I can compare their features, but not really the overall user experience from the perspective of fellow Tivo users. Quirks that might annoy me that others might not notice because they weren't used to something different, or features I don't realize how much I miss until they're gone. Stuff like that. I've been a loyal Tivo customer since 2005, and they've treated me well over the last eight years. After that amount of time I think I'd also go into Tivo UI withdrawal, unless I went with the THR22 (though two tuners isn't really enough for me, I barely squeak by on two plus a separate cable box to record two HD channels + watch one live). Plus losing wishlists and suggestions. Any suggestions? Any Premiere owners switch to satellite and are unhappy? It's costing me a lot of money sticking with cable (more than $800 over the first two years) to keep the Tivo around, but even so I'm really on the fence.