With all apologies to Ninny, Hollie won the night. The judges are correct when they state that she is peaking at just the right time. Both songs were great but I can't help but remember that River Deep, Mountain High was the song that got Pia sent home last year. That scares me a little. Skylar gets my second place vote based primarily on her cover of Fortunate Son. I liked the second song but not as much as the judges. Jessica come in third despite me not loving her versions of either tune. But regardless of whether I loved them or not they both proved that she is a powerhouse vocalist who can get her growl on for Proud Mary and then sing ever so tender with You Are So Beautiful. Joshua - I liked the first half of both songs until he started screeching then he lost me on both of them. Of course he racked up yet another standing ovation, which if Skylar's count last week was right would make his 13th of the season. Phillip - Phillip's lack of range and variety is becoming more apparent with each show that passes. Like last week I think he used backup vocalists to help mask the fact that he can't reliably hit the high notes as needed in Time of The Season. Both Phillip and Joshua also gets points removed for the absolute awkwardness of their pre duet interview. Apparently Joshua forgot that he had to talk into the mic and not mumble. Joshua also loses points for a bizarre, female style, plunging neckline on his shirt. Honestly I do not know who will go home. I know that as usual I want Joshua to go home, if not Joshua then phillip. Jessica has the most consistantly strong voice. Skylar and Hollie are peaking at the right time and have the best personalities.I would have no problem with them being the final three although if Phillip is getting the teen female votes then he may spoil it. At this stage of the game though, win or lose, I think they are probably all assured of getting an album released.